Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Sigh, Why I quit Airliners

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Sigh, Why I quit Airliners

    Well I was not going to make a song and dance of. I was happy to have my images deleted and move on. I thank the genuine emails I have recieved in regards to this and I was not surprised to see a few of the opinions from the other side.

    I read somewhere from Jeff that I am not irreplaceable, and with that I agree whole heartedly. In fact I believed that for a week there would be a bit of discussion and then things would go back to normal. I did not believe I would be missed and in all honesty I wont be. I have just changed channels.

    I have seen the mulltitude of reasons as to why I left Airliners and it is quite amusing what has been said. Some close, some mnowhere near it.

    My reasons for leaving Airliners Net are basically I do not agree with the direction the site is going. I do not believe that the photographers that are supporting the site are in return being given the due respect that they deserve. Remember, i was once a screener, I have seen what goes on behind the scenes. Basically it has been suggested that i have taken my bat and ball and gone home. So be it, I can see that point of view and I can live with it. Having my photos removed was not a decision I took lightly. I had spoken to several Screeners in regards to this previously before doing so. Having done so, I am more comfortable with my decision than I thought I would be. The discussions that Johan has had with ADG on this have no bearing on me whatsoever. I have not spoken to ADG ( although she has a abetter grasp than some, I did not consult her, and she did not tell me to) or any other person in regards to why I have done this apart from 2 people that asked me in an email and they got an abridged version. I appreciate that Johan has an Agenda and he does what he see's fit but I look at it as I am a customer as well, and quite frankly, I prefer to shop where I the service is better. I found that at this site.

    It has absolutely nothing to do wit any moderators, no matter how much they want to take credit.

    My decision to remove myself as a screener was basically, I couldn't accept the criteria that i was supposed to pass down. Sure the rules are in place for what is acceptable but you can take those rules to reject what ever you want, and you can see that happening. Still I have no problems with any one who chooses to use any sites. This is one thing that i could not agree with Johan on when he demanded 100 per cent loyalty to his site and his site only. It's only a damn website after all. I can safely say, there was no favoratism and accusations levelled at Joe Pries are unfounded. In fact Joe has been harshly treated by the screeners in my opinion

    But anyway, the reason I am having to do this is no surprise that certain Crew Members are now publicly sprouting mis information that johan and I had a big slanging match. I expected some bitching from within from a few (still surprised why a few others haven't) but that's not important. I had initially stopped uploading due to it just being a waste of time but then I gave it once last shot. To have certain Mods now telling people that I threatened to pull my photos if I did not get my own way, is in fact not true. I expressed many times to Johan my displeausure of teh way he was handling it. But the exact contect of what was said was is included below

    Just remove them thanks.

    talking about it, does not change it. how long have i been complaining against bad angles. How many times have you told them they are being too harsh.

    -------Original Message-------

    From: Johan Lundgren
    Date: Saturday, June 14, 2003 23:32:45
    To: Glenn
    Subject: Re: Glenn Alderton

    Stop being such a crybaby. What will you achieve doing this? You will have
    wasted months of upload time and Airliners.net will loose good photos.

    We currently have quite a few new screeners that makes a heck of a lot of
    mistakes, if you're not happy - use the appeal function.

    Take a week to think it over. You know this leads to nothing if what you're
    looking for is change in our screening procedures. You want change you
    should put forward your arguments in a civilized way.

    Thanks,
    Johan


    At 21:50 2003-06-14 +1000, you wrote:
    >Johan.
    >
    >I recently started to re uplaod to your site today.
    >
    >Not happy with the reasons for the multitude of reasons for rejection. I
    >started to appeal but it is obvious to me now that uplaoding to Airliners
    >is at most part not enjoyable. The benefit I get is minimal and the
    >agrevation is high.
    >
    >therefore, I would like to request that you remove all my photos from your
    >site. If what i submit now is not good enough, the previous are obviously
    >of a lesser quality and wont be missed from your site.
    >
    >regadrs
    >
    >Glenn Alderton



    In any case. I have made my decision based on my principles, not on what ADG or any other member has expressed in emails to Moderators or Administrators. I will not respond to any more questions on this. It's time to move on. I can, you should all be able to too.

    My one last parting shot is. Airliners makes the statement that they have the best photos on the web. Well maybe that's true at this point however, the major photographers have not even touched the net yet. You haven't seen the Phil Makanna's or the Duncin Cubits or steve fletchers upload here yet. There are many many more. I personally know of 2 that have been doing air to air of all types of aircraft for many years. The shots these guys put out are beyond belief. If they can't get them on to airliners (and they have tried) because USM is .01 percent off, ot the wingtip is missing or heavens forbid, they can see the pilot n a close formation flight, they will post here. Eventually the pendulum will swing the other way. It's only a matter of time. Already the mages of Neville Dawson is a prime example of this.

    If that's sour grapes. Good. I enjoy Lemons

  • #2
    Great explanation Glenn and I also think you made a good decsion on your actions. Its great to see you here where you are treated fairly and where we listen to your, or anyone elses opinions.

    Hope to see more of your shots in the que very soon!
    E-Mail Me - My Photo's - My Photographer Profile

    Comment


    • #3
      Wow, Glenn, without your photos, the quality of Airliners.net will just erode even more. Although you deny it, Airliners.net WILL miss your collection. They have lost another class act.
      AIRIGAMI.NET
      http://www.airigami.net - The next generation of paper airliner modeling.

      Comment


      • #4
        Hi Glenn,
        I have admired your photos on a.net for a while now and I am glad that you have joined us here. Thank you for that long explanation which clears things up. I hope to see some of your work here.

        Stephen

        Comment


        • #5
          Glenn,

          We are delighted you have chosen to grace our site with your amazing pictures, some of which are truly breathtaking. I hope we see all your collection up here one day.

          We welcome criticsisim and complaints here, it's the only way we can change and improve things for the visitors, because one thing we will never forget is that this site would not exist without the contributions of our photographers, and of course Chris and his admin team who put a tremendous amount of work into this site.
          I hope you find it an enjoyable and pleasant experience here, and that you regain your enthusiasm for sharing your stunning pictures with the wider World.

          Regards

          Garry
          Garry Lewis

          Air Team Images - www.airteamimages.com
          Air Traffic Controller - Toronto ACC (West Low)

          https://flic.kr/ps/AAWk8

          Comment


          • #6
            "You haven't seen the Phil Makanna's or the Duncin Cubits or steve fletchers upload here yet. There are many many more. I personally know of 2 that have been doing air to air of all types of aircraft for many years."

            I just wanted to add this of one of the main oddities of a.net. I know a considerable number of aviation photographers who simply do not upload to a.net (and to be fair, other sites aswell). The other irony of a.net is that theres an awful alot of trash on there as well.

            Comment


            • #7
              Glenn,

              I know that the reply you have just compiled couldnt be MORE true. I whole heartedly agree that most of the prime av. photographers dont even post on websites that are photo galleries. Only a small fraction use auction sites. I can name guys here forever that I have got to know over the short 3 years I have been in this business. The unimaginable amounts of rare slides with triple hybrid L1011s in airline colors that never got off the ground is tremendous.

              I think all we can do here is to make a comfortable atmosphere for those that want to join and enjoy this kind of thing. I think the most important thing that counts here is enjoyment and pride. And the most enjoyable moment should be when you press that shutter button for "your" perfect shot and the 2nd one being uploading it on the web for others to enjoy.

              Futhermore, to add to the fact no one is on a steady payroll here (except Chris of course) so it is a hobby for us all and a hobby/job for Chris. On this basis, imagine if Chris told all of the photographers exclusively where to go and what to look at..Thats what the policy looks like on the other side of the mirror.

              I really doubt that there all sane souls here that have seen your photos know not only how good you are but what you stand for. Hell, that 727 you shoot shooting into the sky was on my desktop for more than half a year. I will tell you why so many people look up to you and enjoy your work, because you are not good or great, you are one hell of a legend when it comes to aviation photography. YOU are the person people try to copy when they go to the airport. Maybe they have seen that unique angle that you have tried or that diffrent lighting and they try it for themselves. Personally, I have learned PLENTY from you on how to capture an aircraft (Even though on a scale of 1-100 your a 99.9 and im a 9.99) I think that your image and how others view you is very important in this world (And I do some stupid stuff that hurts it, but im Polish so thats fine.) I can safely say that everyone except a few sour grapes as you have put it view you as a man with an extreme photographic eye which is one hell of a unique skill to posses.

              Now that Im done boring you to death. I just hope JetPhotos can do good where others failed and not go down the dark path of *power*

              PS: Prolly the longest post of my career that you will see
              Legia Warszawa - Duma Stolicy Polski
              Sail the Smooth Skies to ORD with the 767-300ER

              Photos: http://www.jetphotos.net/showphotos.php?userid=5
              http://www.jetphotos.net/members/viewprofile.php?id=5

              Comment


              • #8
                Thanks for the honest explanation. You did not need to do this, but I respect you for it.

                v/r
                Jeff

                Comment


                • #9
                  What Glenn doesn't give is a timeline. He has been pursuing the rights of the uploaders for over a year, probably closer to two. How much time does a site need to address issues that the administrator admits to having?

                  I think this little gem sums it all up:

                  Stop being such a crybaby.
                  So fitting the administrator of a so called professional site.

                  We currently have quite a few new screeners that makes a heck of a lot of
                  mistakes, if you're not happy - use the appeal function.
                  and here he tries to blame his new screeners for an ongoing problem.

                  Oh well, we could talk about this till the cows come home, but the fact is .... if Glenn is happier here, who are we to argue?



                  My only wish is that the speculators would stop tying my leaving the site to Glenn removing his images, as you can see they are mutually exclusive and issue independant.






                  ADG
                  ADG
                  No makeovers please .....

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Glenn, too bad you left but I respect your reasons.


                    ADG, sorry, there is nothing HUMANLY possible to deter speculator's from exercising their opinions.



                    best with warbirdz
                    Witness the miracle of flight.
                    Click Here to view my aircraft photos at JetPhotos.Net!

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      You seem to be quite effective at removing comments you don't wish to read over at airliners.net Mario .. I notice the same doesn't hold true on other comments though ....

                      funny really as the rules are supposed to be the same regardless of subject. Guess all that crying about no bias was as honest as other subjects





                      ADG
                      ADG
                      No makeovers please .....

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        as always, your highness, you are right :
                        Witness the miracle of flight.
                        Click Here to view my aircraft photos at JetPhotos.Net!

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          I don't think that was ever in question





                          ADG
                          ADG
                          No makeovers please .....

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Welcome Glenn - anet loss is certainly JetPhoto's gain - at least here the boss is willing to listen (and act) on advice/critisism. A lot of people feel that the screening rules are too tough now - but (i guess) as long as there are people still uploading work then nothing is going to change.

                            How many more top quality photographers is anet going to loose before something is done (probably a lot) but by that time it will be too late. The reputation of the site is imho already decreasing as a result of this and other problems

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              I respect the decisions of photographers, including Glenn, who change sites or choose site one site over another, although I do not always agree with their justifications. We all have that right to choose where we contribute based on what we want to achieve, and revise that choice as time goes on.

                              Whilst expression of opinion can occasionally influence, I actually see little difference between the moaning about standards of the other site, and the moaning about changing standards here - check out the forum, as this site is certainly not immune from whinging about its own rising standards, and its firmness in applying those standards. The only difference is that they are different standards that are being moaned about.

                              None of the major sites are "wrong" regarding their policies and standards or how they are implemented - they are merely different, and as voluntary contributors to those sites (as photographers and/or workers) we all make decisions from time to time about which sites we can live with most comfortably.

                              Andy

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X