Bad Motive?

[philh]

Sorry to be cheeky and ask advice on another pic (its the last time, I promise!) but would this get rejected for bad motive.

I personally think it would, quite rightly, but I like the shot so would like to upload it but maybe one for the personals folder.

[Crism]

I like it, but I'd prefer to see more of the airplane

[Longreach747]

bad motive-cut off...not enough plane

[BA747-436]

Agree with Monty. To tight a crop

[philh]

Yep, thats what I thought.

It`s hardly cropped though. I just wanted the original pic to be like that, so it`s definitely one for the personal collection.

Thanks for the feedback everyone.

[wwshack]

Ask yourself, "What does this picture say?"

Unfortunately, it does not say all that much to me. You could have used the Flying Club titles as a point of interest but that's cropped off, and the depth of field is too narrow to pull all three aircraft together and there is not much to compare the Cherokees against either.
One for the personal album.

However, never be afraid to experiment. Rebel against side-on shots!

[robw]

And no need to say it's the last time you'll post!! Keep asking questions. You'll always get helpful advice here.

[BA747-436]

Questions = answers. Answers = knoledge. Knoledge = experiance....
See where im going here?

[philh]

lol, thanks chaps.

Just dont want to be a pain in the arse with loads of "would this get accepted" questions and I`m a bugger for trying to capture something different so it could be an oft used question!

[egll]

lol, thanks chaps.
I`m a bugger for trying to capture something different

At last, someone with an open mind!!

*admits to being a hypocrite*


Matt

[Mark Ralph]

Questions = answers. Answers = knoledge. Knoledge = experiance....
See where im going here?

Dictionaries can also help with Knowledge & Experience.

Joking aside, having trained many people in my working enviroment I always tell them "If your not sure ask" I would much rather someone ask how to do something a dozen times rather than sort out problems when it they cock it up.

[tsentsan]

I think it might be nice if you had all the props lined up and perhaps cropped it in such a way.....just my opinion..