Steve Worner - prescreening request / editing advice

[dlowwa]

Thank you again. Can I please get an indication as to whether this image has JP potential?

Not a very attractive angle, this whole side of the aircraft is in shadow. As such, likely contrast/dark/backlit rejection.

[steveworner]

Thanks for the advice, I won't persist with that one any further.

Can I get an opinion on this pic?

[dlowwa]

Thanks for the advice, I won't persist with that one any further.

Can I get an opinion on this pic?

Minus dust and editing halos, should be ok.

[steveworner]

Is this version an improvement?

[dlowwa]

Is this version an improvement?

It would also be rejected for overprocessed.

[steveworner]

Thanks for the advice, I've re-done it with minimal processing. How does it look?

[dlowwa]

Thanks for the advice, I've re-done it with minimal processing. How does it look?

Editing halos still present.

[steveworner]

Thanks: I'll give that one a rest, it's giving me too much frustration!

Has this one got JP potential?

[dlowwa]

Thanks: I'll give that one a rest, it's giving me too much frustration!

Has this one got JP potential?

Would be rejected for dark/contrast. Possibly fixable.

[steveworner]

How about this version?

[LX-A343]

How about this version?

Hardly any difference. Still too dark and lacking contrast.

[steveworner]

How about this version?

[dlowwa]

How about this version?

Brighter, but still borderline for contrast.

[steveworner]

When you say ‘borderline for contrast’, are you saying the image currently has too much contrast, or not enough?

[LX-A343]

When you say ‘borderline for contrast’, are you saying the image currently has too much contrast, or not enough?

borderline means exactly that: borderline. Maybe it will get accepted, maybe not.