Steve Worner - prescreening request / editing advice

[steveworner]

But you think contrast is the issue that will determine that?

[dlowwa]

But you think contrast is the issue that will determine that?

Not enough, still too dark (and yellow). See the right side here:

[steveworner]

Thank you. This pic of an A380 was taken right on dusk, so the ambient light is low and warm in tone. Would it make the cut?

[LX-A343]

Thank you. This pic of an A380 was taken right on dusk, so the ambient light is low and warm in tone. Would it make the cut?

Definitely too dark.

[steveworner]

I've given the tone curve a few tweaks:

[dlowwa]

I've given the tone curve a few tweaks:

Still dark/poor contrast. Don't think this is fixable.

[steveworner]

Ok, thanks - I won't put any more time into that one.

Do you think this one would be okay?

[dlowwa]

Ok, thanks - I won't put any more time into that one.

Do you think this one would be okay?

A touch dark, but otherwise should be ok.

[steveworner]

Thank you! speaking of A330s, there are two pics below (sequential), how do they look to you?

[dlowwa]

Thank you! speaking of A330s, there are two pics below (sequential), how do they look to you?

These would be rejected for similar.

[steveworner]

Do you mean the two pictures are similar? if so, I do apologise for the misunderstanding: would either one of them make the cut?

[dlowwa]

Do you mean the two pictures are similar? if so, I do apologise for the misunderstanding: would either one of them make the cut?

Same aircraft, no? If so, they would be rejected for similar.

[steveworner]

What I mean is, I want to submit one image only of that A330, not two. Are either of those images suitable?

[dlowwa]

What I mean is, I want to submit one image only of that A330, not two. Are either of those images suitable?

I understand that, but it's up to you to choose which one you want to go with - especially if you're asking for prescreening.

[steveworner]

Ah, okay - can I get feedback on this image?