Pre-Screening by Roland 74

[Roland74]

Hello

I reacted to a picture that was rejected and wrote back.
The picture is a Swiss HB-JHB in the start.
Very similar to this picture, https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/9639897

I didn't get a response from JP to my reaction, but the image disappeared in the list of rejected images.
In my database the picture is also not to be found
Can someone tell me exactly what the problem is? Thanks

Roland

[dlowwa]

Hello

I reacted to a picture that was rejected and wrote back.
The picture is a Swiss HB-JHB in the start.
Very similar to this picture, https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/9639897

I didn't get a response from JP to my reaction, but the image disappeared in the list of rejected images.
In my database the picture is also not to be found
Can someone tell me exactly what the problem is? Thanks

Roland

I think we noticed this too. Someone was supposed to have replied to you, but if not, please post a version of the rejected image here, and we can discuss it.

[Roland74]

Hello

It's about this picture, http://www.rfotomoments.ch/mygalleries/Test/HB-JHB1.jpg

The reason for the rejection was horizon and exposure.

I have reacted to the rejection that I find no error in the horizon (see this link)

http://www.rfotomoments.ch/mygalleries/Test/HB-JHB.jpg

That the exposure should actually be ok.

I did not receive an answer to these arguments, but the picture disappeared in this catalogue after 24 hours.

Regards Roland

[dlowwa]

Hello

It's about this picture, http://www.rfotomoments.ch/mygalleries/Test/HB-JHB1.jpg

The reason for the rejection was horizon and exposure.

I have reacted to the rejection that I find no error in the horizon (see this link)

http://www.rfotomoments.ch/mygalleries/Test/HB-JHB.jpg

That the exposure should actually be ok.

I did not receive an answer to these arguments, but the picture disappeared in this catalogue after 24 hours.

Regards Roland

If I recall from our discussion on the senior crew, it was added on appeal, but there appears to have been a system error. You can put it in the queue and let me know, and I'll add it.

[Roland74]

Hello

I uploaded the picture, it has the number Queue ID.8003907

Thanks for your support

[Alex - Spot-This !]

It's now in the db

[Roland74]

Hello JP-Team


This morning a picture was rejected, the screener gave me a hint how to edit the picture to make it ok for the DB.

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=8773863

My question now is if the new picture is ok?

http://www.rfotomoments.ch/mygalleries/Test/CS-TJRKorrektur10.01.21.jpg

Thank you for your support

[dlowwa]

Hello,

Please read here when you get the chance, especially #4:

https://forums.jetphotos.com/forum/aviation-photography-videography-forums/digital-photo-processing-forum/63048-suggestions-when-asking-for-editing-advice-prescreening-from-crew

In the future please continue to use this thread; any new threads opened will simply be deleted.

This morning a picture was rejected, the screener gave me a hint how to edit the picture to make it ok for the DB.

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=8773863

My question now is if the new picture is ok?

http://www.rfotomoments.ch/mygalleries/Test/CS-TJRKorrektur10.01.21.jpg

Contrast is somewhat improved, but I would still consider it borderline due to the cloudy/overcast conditions.

[Roland74]

Hello

Thanks for the note, could you possibly change the title for me "Pre-Screening by Roland 74"

I have edited the image again and uploaded it.

Hello,

Please read here when you get the chance, especially #4:

https://forums.jetphotos.com/forum/aviation-photography-videography-forums/digital-photo-processing-forum/63048-suggestions-when-asking-for-editing-advice-prescreening-from-crew

In the future please continue to use this thread; any new threads opened will simply be deleted.

[Roland74]

Hello

I would like to ask you if there is a way to make the picture acceptable with the tower as a whole (not cropped). Or is this only possible with big aeroplanes because they have less image material at the edge. I was refused a picture today for this reason, so wanted to ask here now for possibilities.

Thank you

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=8777425

[hkgaviationspotting]

Hey there! I'm not a screener but just wanted to offer my opinion. I think that the crop may be too wide and to make it acceptable you must crop tighter and make the aircraft the main subject. The photo is also not centered well so may need adjusting before reupload.

As this is only my opinion, you should wait for screeners to give their thoughts on it as well.

Hope this helps a bit!

[Roland74]

I know JP's rules of what a picture has to look like in order for it to be accepted. I think it's a shame when you see the tower cut off very often in the pictures. There may be a little room for creativity. Hence my question to the team.

Perhaps there is room for such images simply under other options (airport, tower, etc.)

[dlowwa]

I know JP's rules of what a picture has to look like in order for it to be accepted. I think it's a shame when you see the tower cut off very often in the pictures. There may be a little room for creativity. Hence my question to the team.

Perhaps there is room for such images simply under other options (airport, tower, etc.)

No idea why you didn't just go with a 4:3 crop.. looks nearly acceptable to me like that:



Probably work better with an aircraft that's a bit longer, but you get the point.

[Roland74]

No idea why you didn't just go with a 4:3 crop.. looks nearly acceptable to me like that:


Probably work better with an aircraft that's a bit longer, but you get the point.

Thanks for your advice, I will try my luck.

[Roland74]

Hello I have 2 questions

Question 1
I would like to have 3 images on the JP database.

https://www.jetphotos.com/showphotos.php?location=Zurich-Kloten%20Airport%20-%20LSZH&reg=A6-EES&userid=57220

http://www.rfotomoments.ch/mygalleries/Test/A6-EES.jpg

http://www.rfotomoments.ch/mygalleries/Test/A6-EES1.jpg

Are the new two accepted?

Question 2

http://www.rfotomoments.ch/mygalleries/Test/A6-EES.jpg

I have straightened this picture horizontally, but the tower of the church still seems crooked to me, what is your opinion.

Thank you for the help.
Roland