Rainsmains - Prescreening Request/Editing Advice

[Rainsmains]

Would this photo be better?

[Rainsmains]

Could I get a pre-screen for this image? I know it would probably get a bad crop, but to allow for a tight crop with not much dead space the plane has to be slightly lower, May i ask if that is acceptable?

Would this also be better?

[dlowwa]

Would this also be better?

Slightly better, but still borderline.

[Rainsmains]

Improved from definite rejection to possible rejection (borderline) for soft. Also notice some vignetting on right side, but that was there in the first version as well.
.

Would this be better?

[Rainsmains]

Could I get a prescreen for this shot? I intend to upload it with the artistic effect category. Thank you!

[dlowwa]

Could I get a prescreen for this shot? I intend to upload it with the artistic effect category. Thank you!

Don't think the centering really works.

[Rainsmains]

Would be rejected for soft, contrast, overexposed, vignetting, and horizon.

May I ask if this is better? Thank you!

[Rainsmains]

Could I get a prescreening for these 2 pictures if it is not too much? Thank You!

[dlowwa]

1. contrast, centering
2-3 soft

[Rainsmains]

1. contrast, centering
2-3 soft

Could i just ciarlfy with you what you mean by contrast (Is it too little or too much?) and centering (Whats wrong with it?)

I understand that centering is defined as like aircraft not being able to take the center spot, but from what i see, the crop seems alright (Vertical stabilizer not cut, all 4 engines in frame, only thing cut would be the part of the wings (which gives too much dead space anyways))

[dlowwa]

Could i just ciarlfy with you what you mean by contrast (Is it too little or too much?)

Poor light due to overcast conditions.

and centering (Whats wrong with it?)

Too low in frame.

[Rainsmains]

Poor light due to overcast conditions.

For this the contrast, would it be fixable? If so, how could i make it Better (Sorry, Im not really good at this part of post processing!)

[Rainsmains]

3 soft

Would this be better? or still boderline?




Could I also get a prescreen for these 2 posts? Thank you!

[dlowwa]

For this the contrast, would it be fixable?

Doubt it.

Would this be better? or still boderline?

Still a bit soft towards the edges but would be ok for me.

Could I also get a prescreen for these 2 posts? Thank you!

1. color/contrast, soft
2. dirty, borderline soft

[Rainsmains]

2. dirty, borderline soft

Would this be better?