Hayes Barton - Pre-screening request

[dlowwa]

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=10409254

This one, rejection: - bad Info: aircraft.
But I didn't find bad info
Would like to have a more detailed explanation
thanks

There was a bug when screening so that info appeared blank. It has now been accepted.

[Hayes Barton]

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=10409254

This one, rejection: - bad Info: aircraft.
But I didn't find bad info
Would like to have a more detailed explanation
thanks

[dlowwa]

I did some sharpening. Is it still soft now?

Acceptable for me, but can't speak for others.

[Hayes Barton]

Slightly soft.

I did some sharpening. Is it still soft now?

[dlowwa]

HI~
I'd like to get some editorial advice.

Slightly soft.

[Hayes Barton]

HI~
I'd like to get some editorial advice.

[dlowwa]

HI~
I'd like to get some editorial advice.This one is rare.

Dirty and a touch soft. Otherwise ok for me.

[Hayes Barton]

HI~
I'd like to get some editorial advice.This one is rare.

[dlowwa]

Compared with the previous one, is this one more appropriate? Do you have more editorial suggestions?

Same potential contrast issues, and this one is softer.

[Hayes Barton]

Borderline contrast/noise, and might need a little CCW rotation.

Compared with the previous one, is this one more appropriate? Do you have more editorial suggestions?

[dlowwa]

HI~
I'd like to get some editorial advice.

Borderline contrast/noise, and might need a little CCW rotation.

[Hayes Barton]

HI~
I'd like to get some editorial advice.

[dlowwa]

HI~
I'd like to get some editorial advice.
P1 Is it backlight?

No.

P2 Such composition does it exist Part of aircraft cut off

Composition ok.

P3 Any noise or grain？

Some noise, but acceptable for me.

P4 Is there a problem with the contrast?

Somewhat. I would consider it borderline.

[Hayes Barton]

HI~
I'd like to get some editorial advice.
P1 Is it backlight?
P2 Such composition does it exist Part of aircraft cut off
P3 Any noise or grain？
P4 Is there a problem with the contrast?

More suggestions are welcome.
Thank you.

[Hayes Barton]

I´m not screener, but for me both are soft and noisy. And yes, both can be submitted because is a different angle/side of the airplane.

Thank you for your advice. It's very helpful to me~