prescreening request / editing advice

[dlowwa]

Does this mean that I need to increase the sharpening further and do some more clockwise rotation?

Up to you. Not sure more sharpening will help as there's already noise starting to become apparent.

[Qixuan Zhang]

Up to you. Not sure more sharpening will help as there's already noise starting to become apparent.

Thank you for your patient guidance.

[Qixuan Zhang]

Hello scanner, please help me check if the following five photos are acceptable or how to re-edit. Thanks in advance.

[dlowwa]

Hello scanner, please help me check if the following five photos are acceptable or how to re-edit. Thanks in advance.

Contrast a bit harsh on #4, but otherwise they would be ok for me.

[Qixuan Zhang]

Contrast a bit harsh on #4, but otherwise they would be ok for me.

Thank you for your reply.

[Qixuan Zhang]

Hello screener, I would like to know if the following five photos will be rejected, and how to edit them further. There is another request, please help me check if there is still dust to be removed, because I was rejected yesterday because of dust, but I can't see it on the original picture, so I uploaded it. But I now think it may be that my eyes are not sharp enough, or the computer screen is not good enough.Thanks in advance.

[dlowwa]

Hello screener, I would like to know if the following five photos will be rejected, and how to edit them further. There is another request, please help me check if there is still dust to be removed, because I was rejected yesterday because of dust, but I can't see it on the original picture, so I uploaded it. But I now think it may be that my eyes are not sharp enough, or the computer screen is not good enough.Thanks in advance.

1-4. borderline noisy (sky is noisy in all)
5. also noisy, and poor contrast/color (blue tint) as well

Don't see any dust.

[Qixuan Zhang]

1-4. borderline noisy (sky is noisy in all)
5. also noisy, and poor contrast/color (blue tint) as well

Don't see any dust.

understood. Thank you for your reply.

[Qixuan Zhang]

Hello screener, I would like to know whether the following five photos will be rejected, and the reasons for their rejection, in order to further edit them. The last one was taken at Sanya Phoenix International Airport (ZJSY). Thanks in advance.

[dlowwa]

Hello screener, I would like to know whether the following five photos will be rejected, and the reasons for their rejection, in order to further edit them. The last one was taken at Sanya Phoenix International Airport (ZJSY). Thanks in advance.

1 + 3 ok for me
2 + 4 borderline overexposed
5 borderline contrast

[Qixuan Zhang]

1 + 3 ok for me
2 + 4 borderline overexposed
5 borderline contrast

Contrast a bit harsh（or weak） on #5？

[dlowwa]

Contrast a bit harsh（or weak） on #5？

Harsh.. probably would have been better if the aircraft weren't backlit.

[Qixuan Zhang]

Harsh.. probably would have been better if the aircraft weren't backlit.

This is indeed the case, I agree, but unfortunately my photography skills were very poor at that time, so I can only rely on post-editing now. I edited these pictures again, do they look acceptable to JP now?

[dlowwa]

This is indeed the case, I agree, but unfortunately my photography skills were very poor at that time, so I can only rely on post-editing now. I edited these pictures again, do they look acceptable to JP now?

1. ok for me
2. borderline dark
3. borderline contrast

[Qixuan Zhang]

1. ok for me
2. borderline dark
3. borderline contrast

How does the photo look now?（Last try, thank you.）