Prescreening / postprocessing rejection advice

[dlowwa]

Hello,

Can I have a feedback about this photo, please ?

Image is soft and dark.

[Jean-Philippe SL]

Hello,

Can I have a feedback about this photo, please ?



Jean-Philippe

[dlowwa]

I didn't often see photos with portrait orientation on JP so I was not sure that is accepted. But yes in the case of this photo this could be better:

Crop works much better for me, but there is a loss of quality with the larger crop. Somewhat soft & noisy now. Could also be a bit brighter.

[Jean-Philippe SL]

I didn't often see photos with portrait orientation on JP so I was not sure that is accepted. But yes in the case of this photo this could be better:

[dlowwa]

Thank you, I have cropped closer to the plane like this, is it better ?

Yes, but not sure why you aren't using a 4:3 crop, or even a portrait orientation. As it is the centering looks off. Would need brightening as well if you get the crop sorted out.

[Jean-Philippe SL]

Thank you, I have cropped closer to the plane like this, is it better ?

[dlowwa]

Hello,

I would like to have an advice about this picture, please:

A lot of empty space, but quality otherwise looks decent to me.

[Jean-Philippe SL]

Hello,

I would like to have an advice about this picture, please:



Jean-Philippe

[Jean-Philippe SL]

Okay, thank you for your answer. I will try with a little bit lower resolution.

[dlowwa]

Hello,

I propose a new versions of the precedent pictures and with a new one:

These would be ok for me, but I could see someone potentially thinking them a bit soft for the resolution.

[Jean-Philippe SL]

Hello,

I propose a new versions of the precedent pictures and with a new one:



Thank you in advance
Jean-Philippe

[dlowwa]

Thank you. I had tried to make my Air arabia better, is it better like this ?
And, what do you think about theses new one, please:

1. dark/harsh contrast
2. too far
3. borderline soft/contrast

[Jean-Philippe SL]

Thank you. I had tried to make my Air arabia better, is it better like this ?



And, what do you think about theses new one, please:

[dlowwa]

Thank you for your previous advices, I tried to make 2 and 3 better, what do you think about ?

And I would to submit this new one

1-2. borderline soft, better chance at lower resolution
3. contrast too harsh

[Jean-Philippe SL]

Thank you for your previous advices, I tried to make 2 and 3 better, what do you think about ?


And I would to submit this new one:


Have a good day
Jean-Philippe