ms spot- prescreening advice

[ms spot]

Thus, I would be great if you prescreeneed these two images too!

[dlowwa]

Thus, I would be great if you prescreeneed these two images too!

1. ok for me
2. borderline heat haze

[ms spot]

Unfortunately, the Photos above were rejected for Undersharpened/soft, Parts of aircraft Cut Off (Finnair) and Undersharpened/soft (Aerotranscargo).

Concerning the First Photo, I really do Not understand why it should be soft as it's scaled down nearly as much as possible and kind of Sharp in the original Version. The Obstruction is maybe subjective but I think I have already had similar Photos accepted.

The Second Photo's quality is in my opinion much worse but I think it should have rather been rejected for Heat Haze than soft.

I would Like to know why the screener's opinions regarding These two- I'd say Kind of usual photos- differ that drastically from each other and If the rejection reasons are totally understandable or If there's been a "mistake" in the screening process (or in the Forum prescreening, but do Not Take it as criticism).


Note: My device Tends to Transform english words Into German, which Makes it extremely difficult to write Texts without any grammar mistakes- Sorry for the incovenience!

[dlowwa]

Unfortunately, the Photos above were rejected for Undersharpened/soft, Parts of aircraft Cut Off (Finnair) and Undersharpened/soft (Aerotranscargo).

Concerning the First Photo, I really do Not understand why it should be soft as it's scaled down nearly as much as possible and kind of Sharp in the original Version. The Obstruction is maybe subjective but I think I have already had similar Photos accepted.

The Second Photo's quality is in my opinion much worse but I think it should have rather been rejected for Heat Haze than soft.

I would Like to know why the screener's opinions regarding These two- I'd say Kind of usual photos- differ that drastically from each other and If the rejection reasons are totally understandable or If there's been a "mistake" in the screening process (or in the Forum prescreening, but do Not Take it as criticism).


Note: My device Tends to Transform english words Into German, which Makes it extremely difficult to write Texts without any grammar mistakes- Sorry for the incovenience!

Cut off for the first? I suppose the tow vehicle is indeed cropped awkwardly, but I'll obviously disagree on the softness. Heat haze is a direct cause of softness, so not surprising for the second. Quite often the two reasons can be interchanged - Heat haze causing softness/Soft due to heat haze.

[ms spot]

Hi, I would Like to know why the following Photo was rejected for Bad Composition / Aircraft Not centered
https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=10224906

Thanks!

[MarkLawrence]

Not a screener, but if you look at the centering tool, there is more gap over the top of the fuselage and under it - so it's a little low in the frame.

[dlowwa]

Hi, I would Like to know why the following Photo was rejected for Bad Composition / Aircraft Not centered
https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=10224906

Thanks!

Indeed a bit too low in the frame.

[ms spot]

Hello, I would like to have a prescreening on the following pictures, taken in Lanzarote with my Canon Powershot Camera:

Thank you!

[dlowwa]

Hello, I would like to have a prescreening on the following pictures, taken in Lanzarote with my Canon Powershot Camera:

I see potential issues with (weak) contrast, noise/compression, and sharpness.

[ms spot]

Which of these Pictures has the highest probability of being accepted with a better edit?

Or: Which of these Pictures is less affected by your aforementioned issues?

Thanks again

[dlowwa]

Which of these Pictures has the highest probability of being accepted with a better edit?

Or: Which of these Pictures is less affected by your aforementioned issues?

Thanks again

They are all affected more or less equally.

[ms spot]

Hello, I would like to have an opinion on the following two pictures regarding sharpness and overall quality

Thank you

[dlowwa]

Hello, I would like to have an opinion on the following two pictures regarding sharpness and overall quality

Dark, soft.

[ms spot]

Is it better now?

[dlowwa]

Is it better now?

Still soft.