Oslplanespotting - prescreening request / editing advice

[787Dream]

Thanks! The vignette in pic 2 is the fence at the airport. But you think number 3 should be acceptable without any more editing?

Maybe a touch of contrast? But it seems from the histogram doesn't have more room to this.

[OslPlaneSpotting]

Possibly.

What do you think of this one?

[787Dream]

What do you think of this one?

Not a screener, but maybe a touch soft and a bit harsh contrast. But I like this one.

[OslPlaneSpotting]

Possibly.

What do you think of these two?

[dlowwa]

What do you think of these two?

1. backlit(toplit)/contrast
2. soft, borderline color

[OslPlaneSpotting]

1. backlit(toplit)/contrast
2. soft, borderline color

Thanks! How about this one?

[dlowwa]

Thanks! How about this one?

Borderline overexposed/centering.

[OslPlaneSpotting]

Borderline overexposed/centering.

Cheers! Is this one better?

[787Dream]

Cheers! Is this one better?

Not a screener. The centering has gotten worse. Sorry I saw this a while ago, but I forgot to type it out for you. Both of your work are too low in the frame. I think there are two types of centering approach you could take.
1) You center the fuselage in the middle of the frame

2) Centering the V-stab+bottom of fuselage.


I would prefer 1 because the V-stab does not pose as a dominant feature in your frame.
I used to have a lot of problem with centering, but I learned through trials. I hope this helps!

[OslPlaneSpotting]

Borderline overexposed/centering.

How about this one?

[dlowwa]

How about this one?

I see no difference with the centering, only the horizon.

[OslPlaneSpotting]

I see no difference with the centering, only the horizon.

Ok, but would this or the other photo be acceptable to you?

[dlowwa]

Ok, but would this or the other photo be acceptable to you?

Centering still too low on both; horizon badly off on one.

[OslPlaneSpotting]

Centering still too low on both; horizon badly off on one.

Thanks!!


How about this one?

[dlowwa]

How about this one?

Would be rejected for contrast.