AaroS - prescreening request / editing advice

[AaroS]

1. borderline blurry/oversharpened
2. dirty

1. Is this better?
2. Where is the dirt? I don't understand.

3. Would this image be better?

4. I also have a question about vignette removal/processing. I have used the normal lens corrections in LR to remove vignetting and the image looks ok to my naked eye but the dust checker reveals these huge dark areas in the corners. What to do?




Thank you so much!

[dlowwa]

1. Is this better?
2. Where is the dirt? I don't understand.

3. Would this image be better?

4. I also have a question about vignette removal/processing. I have used the normal lens corrections in LR to remove vignetting and the image looks ok to my naked eye but the dust checker reveals these huge dark areas in the corners. What to do?

1. same as previous
2. ok for me
3. vignetting not that bad for me, but crop is kind of tight

[AaroS]

1. same as previous
2. ok for me
3. vignetting not that bad for me, but crop is kind of tight

Thank you very much!

[AaroS]

Could you pre-screen these? I'm mostly worried about the amount of direct light visible and centering on the first photo and just overall quality on the second photo.Thank you in advance!

[dlowwa]

Could you pre-screen these? I'm mostly worried about the amount of direct light visible and centering on the first photo and just overall quality on the second photo.Thank you in advance!

1. very borderline contrast/vignetting
2. ok for me

[AaroS]

1. very borderline contrast/vignetting
2. ok for me

Thanks! Is this better? I increased the vignetting removal only slightly to avoid the white edges.

[dlowwa]

Thanks! Is this better? I increased the vignetting removal only slightly to avoid the white edges.

Don't see a huge difference.

[AaroS]

Don't see a huge difference.

In terms of contrast or vignetting or both?

[dlowwa]

In terms of contrast or vignetting or both?

Both.

[AaroS]

Both.

Here is the attempted fix, thank you!

[dlowwa]

Here is the attempted fix, thank you!

Still borderline at best for both. To be blunt, this is a terrible angle, as most of the aircraft visible is in shadow. As such, it will never have a great chance of being accepted. I will not comment on it any more.

[AaroS]

Still borderline at best for both. To be blunt, this is a terrible angle, as most of the aircraft visible is in shadow. As such, it will never have a great chance of being accepted. I will not comment on it any more.

Thanks!

[AaroS]

Should the aircraft be higher in the frame?

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=9469194#

And what about this one? You said vignetting that the vignetting wasn't that bad, I understand that it's just your opinion and it's not a guarantee but should I appeal it? I'm thinking I should but I'm not sure, I don't want to abuse the feature.

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=9469579

Thank you for helping me!

[Calvin L]

Should the aircraft be higher in the frame?

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=9469194#

And what about this one? You said vignetting that the vignetting wasn't that bad, I understand that it's just your opinion and it's not a guarantee but should I appeal it? I'm thinking I should but I'm not sure, I don't want to abuse the feature.

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=9469579

Thank you for helping me!

Yes,higher

Vignetting is crystal clear here, you can see it using "Check for dust" feature

[AaroS]

Yes,higher

Vignetting is crystal clear here, you can see it using "Check for dust" feature

Thanks for confirming that!

I know. I posted screenshots of that image with the check for dust in a prior post. I'm just confused because I was told that it isn't too bad.