T.P.F.A - Editing/Pre-screening/Rejection Advice

[T.P.F.A.]

New operator and would be hot if livery is changed.

Hello, recently got the rejection for this photo https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=11000533

I've input the new operator ( in this case Lion Air ) as discussed last time, but got bad info for that. And for categories wrong/missing, I assume in this case special scheme, because I remember selecting that. I think it is special scheme since in this case it's a hybrid (with operated by lion air text below logo). The photo below also in a hybrid livery, as my reference for photo above.

https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/10630993

I need some opinion for this, maybe there is some condition that I have missed when inputting aircraft data. Thank you in advance

[dlowwa]

Hello, recently got the rejection for this photo https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=11000533

I've input the new operator ( in this case Lion Air ) as discussed last time, but got bad info for that. And for categories wrong/missing, I assume in this case special scheme, because I remember selecting that. I think it is special scheme since in this case it's a hybrid (with operated by lion air text below logo). The photo below also in a hybrid livery, as my reference for photo above.

https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/10630993

I need some opinion for this, maybe there is some condition that I have missed when inputting aircraft data. Thank you in advance

Not Special Scheme. Operator Batik Air (Lion Air), but better to ask the editors what they prefer.

[T.P.F.A.]

Not Special Scheme. Operator Batik Air (Lion Air), but better to ask the editors what they prefer.

Okay, i'll be in touch with the editors, thank you for the response

[T.P.F.A.]

Hi there, I would like to ask some questions regarding hot photo. According to Upload Guidelines section 2.5 part 5 (Other Newsworthy events at the discretion of the screening team. (typical hand over ceremonies, promotion tours by new airliner types,..), if it is newsworthy, it can be considered as hot.

Recently I got some c-17 and b-52 landed on my local airport. It's c-17 first time landed on WIMM and b-52 first time landed on any place in Indonesia. They are coming for cope west join exercise between Indonesia Air Force and USAF.

Does that count as hot according to section 2.5 part 5? Thank you in advance

[dlowwa]

Hi there, I would like to ask some questions regarding hot photo. According to Upload Guidelines section 2.5 part 5 (Other Newsworthy events at the discretion of the screening team. (typical hand over ceremonies, promotion tours by new airliner types,..), if it is newsworthy, it can be considered as hot.

Recently I got some c-17 and b-52 landed on my local airport. It's c-17 first time landed on WIMM and b-52 first time landed on any place in Indonesia. They are coming for cope west join exercise between Indonesia Air Force and USAF.

Does that count as hot according to section 2.5 part 5? Thank you in advance

Not hot.

[T.P.F.A.]

Not hot.

Got it. What topic usually count as newsworthy? Is there a list that I can refer to?

[dlowwa]

Got it. What topic usually count as newsworthy? Is there a list that I can refer to?

First flights of a new type are the only ones that usually qualify as newsworthy. Everything else usually not, though it is at our discretion.

[T.P.F.A.]

Quick question, does photo of same aircraft, same spot, but the only difference is one is shot at midday and one is shot at night (not sunrise or sunset, but dark night) does that count as similar?

[dlowwa]

Quick question, does photo of same aircraft, same spot, but the only difference is one is shot at midday and one is shot at night (not sunrise or sunset, but dark night) does that count as similar?

Not going to speculate without seeing the images in question.

[T.P.F.A.]

Don't have the photo in the same spot yet, but I have the photo for reference


Also would like to hear some opinion about the night one. Not so sure about the colour but tried my best to match irl condition. Still lots of purple there

[dlowwa]

Don't have the photo in the same spot yet, but I have the photo for reference

Also would like to hear some opinion about the night one. Not so sure about the colour but tried my best to match irl condition. Still lots of purple there

If different dates, should be ok, though night shot is blurry and has no chance of acceptance.

[T.P.F.A.]

If different dates, should be ok, though night shot is blurry and has no chance of acceptance.

Got it. Thank you

[T.P.F.A.]

Hi there, just asking for opinion

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=11210547

I was left puzzled by the reason. Although I have the same aircraft already in database, this one was taken year after, different angle and crop, also the aircraft is visually different from the last one I uploaded, does it still count as similar?

And does the same exact aircraft photos taken by 1 year apart, with part of the livery sticker removed, captured at the same exact angle (one is in takeoff phase, and one is in touchdown phase, so different location) also count as similar? PK-GIJ for example

Thank you in advance.

[T.P.F.A.]

Also would like to hear some opinion about these photos for the cropping. For this instances is about the location. Does portrait shot allowed in this case?

[dlowwa]

Also would like to hear some opinion about these photos for the cropping. For this instances is about the location. Does portrait shot allowed in this case?

None of these really work.