screening help for ronen_fefer

[dlowwa]

Hi everyone

I want to ask about your opinion on the matter of: is the contrast of these photos fixabel?

1. yes
2. no

[ronen_fefer]

Ok so i have fixed the transavia photo, but im not sure if id have fixed the vingetting could someone please tell me if it prisists and how could i fix it?


sincerly Ronen

[dlowwa]

Ok so i have fixed the transavia photo, but im not sure if id have fixed the vingetting could someone please tell me if it prisists and how could i fix it?

Some software can remove it, though you will need to be careful as poor vignetting correction is just as likely to cause a rejection as vignetting itself.

[ronen_fefer]

Some software can remove it, though you will need to be careful as poor vignetting correction is just as likely to cause a rejection as vignetting itself.

Yeah that is all very clear but i am using the adobe photoshop Lightroom camera raw filter and I am not sure I how should I fix the vignetting in the effects tab since it’s very hard to tell how good it is?

any help here maybe?

[dlowwa]

Yeah that is all very clear but i am using the adobe photoshop Lightroom camera raw filter and I am not sure I how should I fix the vignetting in the effects tab since it’s very hard to tell how good it is?

any help here maybe?

Sorry, you'll need to be a lot more specific because "how should I fix the vignetting in the effects tab since it’s very hard to tell how good it is?" does not make it at all clear exactly what your issue is.

[ronen_fefer]

hi question, does this photo still has vingetting on it?

[dlowwa]

hi question, does this photo still has vingetting on it?

There is no vignetting visible, though there are multiple other issues.

[ronen_fefer]

There is no vignetting visible, though there are multiple other issues.

Could I know what are they?

[dlowwa]

Could I know what are they?

Centering, dust spots, overprocessing.

[ronen_fefer]

Centering, dust spots, overprocessing.

Ok i am having a hard time understanding the meaning of overprocessing in this specific case since I don't really see any halos on the photo and centering what reference points should i use to know if it is centered enough to be accepted.

thank you for your replies.

[dlowwa]

Ok i am having a hard time understanding the meaning of overprocessing in this specific case since I don't really see any halos on the photo

Circular banding is visible, likely from vignetting correction.

and centering what reference points should i use to know if it is centered enough to be accepted.

Fuselage should be equidistant from the top/bottom and L/R sides.

[ronen_fefer]

Circular banding is visible, likely from vignetting correction.

How can i Spot it?
to try to find a way to fix it and find a compromise between that and vignetting correction.

And about the centering I that’s well understood, thank you very much.

[dlowwa]

How can i Spot it?

Umm.. look at the image? I find that looking at the thumbnail version can help sometimes as well.

[ronen_fefer]

Hi everyone, could someone do a pre-screening critique of this photo?

Your critique will be greatly appreciated.

[dlowwa]

Hi everyone, could someone do a pre-screening critique of this photo?

Your critique will be greatly appreciated.

It's a nice enough photo.

It can't be uploaded, so no prescreening though.