Originally posted by jhud922
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
jhud922 - editing advice
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by dlowwa View Post
Minor issues with processing (editing halos) on the first, and the second is nearly backlit so likely a rejection for that or dark/contrast.
Comment
-
Originally posted by jhud922 View Post
Thanks. The second one isn't backlit, the sun was about 30 minutes from setting, so its clearly facing nearly head on. Is an aircraft facing into the sunlight like that always frowned upon?
Dynasty 32 from Taipei-Taoyuan (TPE), 26R.. B-18918. Airbus A350-941. JetPhotos.com is the biggest database of aviation photographs with over 5 million screened photos online!
Originally posted by jhud922 View PostCould I get anyone's thoughts on this one?
2. borderline soft (esp. towards tail)
3. overprocessed (editing halos)
Comment
-
Originally posted by dlowwa View Post
Majority of the aircraft facing the photographer in shadow = backlit, as how usually interpreted at JP - so yes, it could very well be considered backlit. If you want to submit an image with the light on the front like that, make sure the front of the aircraft takes up most of the frame.
Dynasty 32 from Taipei-Taoyuan (TPE), 26R.. B-18918. Airbus A350-941. JetPhotos.com is the biggest database of aviation photographs with over 5 million screened photos online!
1. borderline dark/contrast
2. borderline soft (esp. towards tail)
3. overprocessed (editing halos)
Comment
-
Originally posted by jhud922 View Post
thanks - does contrast mean add more, or less? Personally, that China Airlines 777 looks a little too contrasty to me, but i want to be clear.
Comment
-
Originally posted by dlowwa View Post
Majority of the aircraft facing the photographer in shadow = backlit, as how usually interpreted at JP - so yes, it could very well be considered backlit. If you want to submit an image with the light on the front like that, make sure the front of the aircraft takes up most of the frame.
Dynasty 32 from Taipei-Taoyuan (TPE), 26R.. B-18918. Airbus A350-941. JetPhotos.com is the biggest database of aviation photographs with over 5 million screened photos online!
1. borderline dark/contrast
2. borderline soft (esp. towards tail)
3. overprocessed (editing halos)
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by jhud922 View Post
Also for #3, can you show me where you are seeing halos? I've equalized in photoshop and don't see any.
Not terribly strong, but they are there, and as such may cause a rejection.
Originally posted by jhud922 View Post
Ok...so less contrast on the China Airlines then?
Comment
-
Originally posted by jhud922 View Post
lol ok man, i dont see a single thing. I didn't even make any edits lol
Comment
-
Originally posted by dlowwa View Post
Fair enough, but I think I'm going to leave it at that. I'm making an honest effort to provide feedback which you are of course welcome to dismiss in such a manner, but in doing so I think it's clear it's not really worth the effort.
Comment
-
I want to test something here, this image is to me, insane. I can hardly look at it, its blowing out my retinas. However, maybe others disagree? I watched a video tutorial recently by a photographer here who has over 1k photos and a very high acceptance rate. I've essentially copied his technique, and I will share my settings from LR as well. I'd love to know anyone's thoughts on this - aka, would this get accepted were I to upload it?
2022-02-24 18_13_08-Lightroom Catalog-3-2-v10-v11 - Adobe Photoshop Lightroom Classic - Develop by John Hudson, on Flickr
Comment
Comment