JuklicekCZ - Pre-Screening advice

[JuklicekCZ]

Hello,
I just wanted to double-check this rejection.
https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=10614207
It is rejected for cut off because of the tail apparently, however, eventhough the crop is really close I dont think there would actually be a missing part.
Shall I understand the rejection more like a centering issue, or can a close crop result into a cut off as well?

[dlowwa]

Ok, thank you very much for your service.
I ended up uploading them almost unedited (colorwise).
Please don't tell me now, that they are still hash, because now, they are like black -2 in the lightroom sliders.

Ok for me; can't say for others.

[JuklicekCZ]

Ok, thank you very much for your service.
I ended up uploading them almost unedited (colorwise).
Please don't tell me now, that they are still hash, because now, they are like black -2 in the lightroom sliders.

[dlowwa]

Thank you, I have tried to reduce the blacks even more, however, would't the historgram be a problem now?
I mean specifically the gap on the left.

A bit better. I usually don't check the histogram when screening unless I need to confirm something. I suspect most screeners are the same.

[JuklicekCZ]

These are slightly improved.

Thank you, I have tried to reduce the blacks even more, however, would't the historgram be a problem now?
I mean specifically the gap on the left.

[dlowwa]

Thanks, I tried to brighten the darks a bit.
Would these be acceptable?

These are slightly improved.

[JuklicekCZ]

Borderline harsh contrast on the first two, otherwise ok for me.

Thanks, I tried to brighten the darks a bit.
Would these be acceptable?

[dlowwa]

Hello, may I get a feedback on theese?
What concerns me most is contrast, Processing (overprocessed) and sharpness.
Thank you very much

Borderline harsh contrast on the first two, otherwise ok for me.

[JuklicekCZ]

Hello, may I get a feedback on theese?
What concerns me most is contrast, Processing (overprocessed) and sharpness.
Thank you very much

[JuklicekCZ]

Ok, thank you.
Will probably keep it then.

[dlowwa]

Thank you,
And what about this one?
I suppose, that the sharpness should be sufficient, but would isnt the light situation already too problematic?
It was already quite a late afternoon.

Borderline backlit/contrast, and some soft areas.

[JuklicekCZ]

Thank you,
And what about this one?
I suppose, that the sharpness should be sufficient, but would isnt the light situation already too problematic?
It was already quite a late afternoon.

[dlowwa]

Hello,
Would these to be acceptable?
Thanks.

Ok for me.

[JuklicekCZ]

Hello,
Would these to be acceptable?
Thanks.

[JuklicekCZ]

from the same day yes - From the same PHASE no (take-off / landing / taxying / parked ac)

Regards
Alex

Hmm, thank you for the clarification.
But apparently, there were considered to be similar.