Advice/Confirmation requested by jakerepp

[dlowwa]

Wondering if composition on the AA is okay.

Also the other two are new registrations that I managed to shoot at incorrect settings, either 3 stops underexposed or absurdly high ISO and tried to recover. Are either okay?

1. subjective. unappealing for me, but not an automatic rejection.
2. ok for me
3. borderline dark

[jakerepp]

1. subjective. unappealing for me, but not an automatic rejection.
2. ok for me
3. borderline dark

Fair enough. Thanks

[jakerepp]

Airshow/Fly-in day. Pre-screening please, mostly concerned about darkness or motive (faces).

[dlowwa]

Airshow/Fly-in day. Pre-screening please, mostly concerned about darkness or motive (faces).

Light's a bit harsh on first and especially third; don't see any motive issues.

[jakerepp]

Having never tried a silhouette shot, I can't really tell if this is okay. Does it work? The tail maybe looks a bit blurry to me.

[dlowwa]

Having never tried a silhouette shot, I can't really tell if this is okay. Does it work? The tail maybe looks a bit blurry to me.

Centering, borderline contrast (background is a bit bright)

[jakerepp]

Centering, borderline contrast (background is a bit bright)

Something closer to this?

[dlowwa]

Something closer to this?

A bit better, but still would say borderline at best.

[jakerepp]

Do either of these have a chance?

[dlowwa]

Do either of these have a chance?

Probably not.