Tyler/ Prescreening/ Editing Advice for Spotting Location

[dlowwa]

Hey Dana, I have this rejection for horizon unlevel. https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=11742625
The reason I'm asking for your advice is because I see conflicting verticals. The fence, yellow poles and the chimney all look level and they are in the middle. Do you think an appeal would have a chance? Thanks

Needs a little CW rotation. buildings are leaning, poles are less reliable.

[Tyler Godfrey]

Hey Dana, I have this rejection for horizon unlevel. https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=11742625
The reason I'm asking for your advice is because I see conflicting verticals. The fence, yellow poles and the chimney all look level and they are in the middle. Do you think an appeal would have a chance? Thanks

[dlowwa]

Hey Dana, I had this shot of AC's Disney wish 787 rejected for soft. https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=11720097. Do you think it's that soft?
I'm wondering if my new edit is better and acceptable? Thanks

Looks quite badly heat hazed. If not, would need a significantly better edit.

[Tyler Godfrey]

Hey Dana, I had this shot of AC's Disney wish 787 rejected for soft. https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=11720097. Do you think it's that soft?
I'm wondering if my new edit is better and acceptable? Thanks

[Tyler Godfrey]

Hard to tell. Might be ok, but if not then a little ccw.

Thanks, now accepted!

[dlowwa]

Thank you, I'm also wondering if I fixed the horizon on this one?

Hard to tell. Might be ok, but if not then a little ccw.

[Tyler Godfrey]

Slight haze/sharpening issues on the first three, but nearly ok. Last one still badly oversharpened/compressed.

Thank you, I'm also wondering if I fixed the horizon on this one?

[dlowwa]

Thanks, Can you also prescreen these ones?

Slight haze/sharpening issues on the first three, but nearly ok. Last one still badly oversharpened/compressed.

[Tyler Godfrey]

CW.



Dark/harsh contrast

Thanks, Can you also prescreen these ones?

[dlowwa]

Ok, what rotation is needed on it? Both directions look off.

CW.

Prescreening for these ones please? All new regs, thanks

Dark/harsh contrast

[Tyler Godfrey]

It would not.

Ok, what rotation is needed on it? Both directions look off.

Prescreening for these ones please? All new regs, thanks

[dlowwa]

I just got this rejection for horizon unlevel.
I don't understand it because all the verticals look level and with the horizon filter it all looks fine. Would an appeal be successful?

It would not.

[Tyler Godfrey]

Everything is leaning left, needs CW. Aircraft is soft.

Thank you, I will reupload.

I just got this rejection for horizon unlevel. https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=11748631
I don't understand it because all the verticals look level and with the horizon filter it all looks fine. Would an appeal be successful?

[dlowwa]

Thanks,

Could you give me your advice on this rejection for soft and horizon? https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=11712685
I don't really see the unlevel horizon other than the fence. But the fence has conflicting verticals so it's hard to tell.
For the softness, I can't really see softness and if I sharpen it any more it looks oversharpened.
Thank you!

Everything is leaning left, needs CW. Aircraft is soft.

[Tyler Godfrey]

Horizon, borderline oversharpened.

Thanks,

Could you give me your advice on this rejection for soft and horizon? https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=11712685
I don't really see the unlevel horizon other than the fence. But the fence has conflicting verticals so it's hard to tell.
For the softness, I can't really see softness and if I sharpen it any more it looks oversharpened.
Thank you!