Soft rejection

[Greg Wilson]

Can anyone explain this please...
http://www.jetphotos.net/viewreject.php?id=942360

[SkyNevada]

Hi Greg, No - I can't. But I don't work here. It looks awesome to me. Just sharpen it up a bit more and resubmit?

[LX-A343]

I can see, why the screener rejected it (example: windows between cockpit and wing). But I would appeal it.

Gerardo

[Top_Gun]

looks like a great shot, I would be afraid if you tried sharpen it would be rejected again for jaggies...

I would try an appeal myself

[MaxPower]

I can see, why the screener rejected it (example: windows between cockpit and wing). But I would appeal it.

Gerardo

I got this problem a little while ago, How about using selective sharpen to the various spots where it needed to have sharpen abit.

[Will M]

Hi Greg ,

I can explain it....

I was one of the screeners that screened your shot , It's incredibly soft in the front half of the plane , certainly not as sharp as you usually upload

[Billsville]

Greg,

I was another screener on this one.

I also thought the front half of the plane was very soft, noticable around the titles.

Maybe some selective sharpening would be needed?

Steve Brown

[Greg Wilson]

Thanks for the replys.......a bit pushed for time at present.I'll be back with a reply.

[jid]

I would say it is fine as it is Greg, try the appeal route.

Jid

[Greg Wilson]

Im back.
I thought I would reply in detail as it was a hit and run initial post….been a bit busy.
Yes I was a touch surprised at the rejection,compounded by the fact that my last few rejections of much the same quality have been noted as soft or exposure,so basicly I was after some sort of feedback.Thank you all for whatever viewpoint you had.
I have reservations on appealing,and granted it is very integral part of the system,however one would expect (and has been confirmed ) that this photo would have been seen by at least 2 screeners.Now I do not agree with them,but a decision has been made.(arseholes ).
Personally I prefer to re-edit,find another in the sequence or look for a rubbish bin………just the way this old head of mine works.
If it was a one off photo or the que was 10,000 I would probably hit the button.
I'll throw it through PS tomorrow.