Advice on appeals

[gregor]

Hi all, Just had these to pics rejected and would like to know if they are worth appealing.

http://www.jetphotos.net/viewreject_b.php?id=1126472

http://www.jetphotos.net/viewreject_b.php?id=1126471

Cheers

[kukkudrill]

Gregor both links are to the same photo. I'm not at the monitor I normally use to edit photos but on this one the upper fuselage does look burnt out.

[MaxPower]

Your BA A320 shot looks funky on my screen. Im interested to know how to avoid this although I'm sure to me it looks like you used Shadow/Highlight fuction here ?

Like the way it looks over here, it lacks the contrast now.

[E-Diddy!]

I was one of the screeners who screened your A320 shot, it looks like you used way too much shadow/highlight. Very noticeable especially underneath the wings.

[JordanD]

I usually only use about 10 on the shadow/highlight tool.

[Alex - Spot-This !]

Hi,
Try to avoid using the shadow/highlight tool as much as possible, especially with shot taken in sunny condition. The 320 is a clear rejection. No need to appeal. the Fokker is not that bad but still overexposed to me.
cheers
Alex

[gregor]

Hi , thanks for the comments guys.

Still not sure about the Fokker being overexposed, while there are some bright areas on it overall i think it is ok, afterall it is a prdominately white aircraft taken on a sunny day.

How about this version of the Airbus?is it worth uploading?

[kukkudrill]

Better but still looks odd to me I'm afraid. How about if you post a cropped and resized but otherwise unedited version of the original?

[Simpleboy]

I took your latest pic and messed around with it somewhat,

Try aim for a bit more contrast under the wings to create a more realistic effect.

[jid]

Blues look over saturated and there is a lack of contrast. Also the exposure needs looking at. I have also had a go at 'fixing' the image but this is only of demo purposes. You do need to fully re-work the image.

Jid