NEW Editing advice thread

[brianw999]

Oh yes, this one is obvious dark. You can have a look your histogram.

Dark and also backlit. Cannot be fixed for upload.

[barcajax]

The screener left you a note in the rejection email Ronald.

Brian, have no mail about this rejection...

[Julian S.]

Hi guys!

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=5858613

Please let me know why this photo is not centered. Is it better when the vertical stab is partly cut off placing the main body in the center? This is the composition to show this plane with the tale in the evening sunshine.
this is an example from my previous compositions: https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/8567272

Use the Windows for centering, they should be in the middle of the frame. Or use Brian´s "How to center a plane" post.

I disagree with the horizon level problem as well. It turns on the end of the taxiway. It looked like as it is. Of course the camera was levelled.

In my opinion, it need some counter clock wise rotation. Look at the RWY in the Background, it should be Horizontal.


Best Regards and always happy spottings.
Julian S.

[B7772ADL]

Brian, have no mail about this rejection...

Ok, as you say that you have no email, it was rejected for soft which IMO is the correct decision and not worth appealing. The aircraft is soft, especially around the tail area. If you want to upload photos at 1920px you must upload only your best quality images. 1920px will make flaws even more noticeable and make it easier to reject. You need to either sharpen it more or downsize it which can have a similar effect.

Hope this helps

[federbear]

The looking angle of the runway is not 90%. Therefore it looks like unlevel.

The composition. The photo is cropped to show the whole body and the tale. If the window would be in center vertically then the top of horizontal stabilizer could go outside of the photo.
Next time perhaps it is best if you comment that you not like this kind of crop or that picture. But then I have to raise a question about other photos that are already accepted with this crop style, because there are many pictures on your site with this crop. Why did you accept these photos then?

Examples

https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/8421880

https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/8123706

https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/8555320

https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/8548751

Regards
federbear

Use the Windows for centering, they should be in the middle of the frame. Or use Brian´s "How to center a plane" post.



In my opinion, it need some counter clock wise rotation. Look at the RWY in the Background, it should be Horizontal.


Best Regards and always happy spottings.
Julian S.

[Julian S.]

The looking angle of the runway is not 90%. Therefore it looks like unlevel.

The composition. The photo is cropped to show the whole body and the tale. If the window would be in center vertically then the top of horizontal stabilizer could go outside of the photo.
Next time perhaps it is best if you comment that you not like this kind of crop or that picture. But then I have to raise a question about other photos that are already accepted with this crop style, because there are many pictures on your site with this crop. Why did you accept these photos then?

Examples

https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/8421880

https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/8123706

https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/8555320

https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/8548751

Regards
federbear

Hello federbear,

I really like this angles and crop style.
Here is one of my photos, which is similar to yours.
https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/8475619
In the photo you can see that im not stand 90° to the RWY too, but i have used it for leveling.

Why did you accept these photos then?

I haven´t accepted or rejected any photo.

The post above is only my personal opinion, but best wait for a screener or try it here: Pre-Screening Thread

Regards

[federbear]

Hello federbear,

I really like this angles and crop style.
Here is one of my photos, which is similar to yours.
https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/8475619
In the photo you can see that im not stand 90° to the RWY too, but i have used it for leveling.


I haven´t accepted or rejected any photo.

The post above is only my personal opinion, but best wait for a screener or try it here: Pre-Screening Thread

Regards

Ok, Thx

[Edwin]

Hello, good day to all.

Had this rejected for Horizon unlevel:

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=5860802

I used the horizontal line on the front bulkhead, between left and right overhead bins, as my reference during edit. Perhaps not the best idea.



Would appreciate advice if cw or ccw rotation is needed to fix this, and what reference points should be used to get correct leveling?

Thanks in advance for the help.

Cheers,
Edwin.

[davepotter]

Edwin

I would suggest this needs at least 0.8CW rotation. Inflight/in cabin pictures are very difficult to level as you don't have a vertical point of reference. But this is definitely leaning to the left. Hopefully that rotation should fix it but use your own judgement as well.

Hope this helps.

[Edwin]

Edwin

I would suggest this needs at least 0.8CW rotation. Inflight/in cabin pictures are very difficult to level as you don't have a vertical point of reference. But this is definitely leaning to the left. Hopefully that rotation should fix it but use your own judgement as well.

Hope this helps.

Thanks very much Dave. Cheers.

[B7772ADL]

The looking angle of the runway is not 90%. Therefore it looks like unlevel.

The composition. The photo is cropped to show the whole body and the tale. If the window would be in center vertically then the top of horizontal stabilizer could go outside of the photo.
Next time perhaps it is best if you comment that you not like this kind of crop or that picture. But then I have to raise a question about other photos that are already accepted with this crop style, because there are many pictures on your site with this crop. Why did you accept these photos then?

Examples

https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/8421880

https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/8123706

https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/8555320

https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/8548751

Regards
federbear

Having looked at your rejection, I can see why it was given a horizon rejection. I understand the runway isn't level and that's fine and acceptable, however if you look at the signs and the markers that are along the runway edge they are all leaning to the right. Not just one or two but all of them. So the image just needs a little CCW rotation to bring them vertical. The runway will still slope but that's ok.

As for the crop, i'm pretty sure that you could get the fuselage more central without cropping the top of the tail off. This may mean a slightly wider crop. The crop that you had rejected is different from the examples you provided anyway. Even in your own pics the aircraft is filling the entire frame from a head on view. This is allowable and looks balanced. This is a 1/4 side on so centering needs to be more along the window line as suggested. The tail will be pretty high in the frame yes.

Hope this helps, James.

[pawelm]

Hi guys, I need your help with this one:

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=5863515

In this case I was expecting contrast, under/overexposure rejection. Maybe even soft/oversharpen, overproccesed. But really, the last reasons I would think of were cut off and unlevel. Is it woth to appeal this one? It maybe wasn't a steady approach, but it was taken like 3 minutes after a hail storm, so there was a possibility pretty strong crosswind. And cut off? I really don't know what to say, most of my recently accepted shots from LHR were "almost wingless", and I have many more similar "cut off" shots accepted in the past.

What do you guys think?

edit: I tried to appeal, but it got rejected without any comments. Can you please point out what's actually wrong with this photo? Is it because of cut flap? Should I crop it tighter or wider? I really don't get it...

[ErezS]

Dear friends,

Please your help to fix the contrast of this photo and Also this photo.

Thanks in advance,
Erez.

[HarryLi]

Dear friends,

Please your help to fix the contrast of this photo and Also this photo.

Thanks in advance,
Erez.

Hello Erez,
I have downloaded your two photos to edit and here is the result of mine. I think is better than yours.




Just for reference~ Hope can help you .
Cheers,
Harry

[pawelm]

Hi guys, I need your help with this one:

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=5863515

In this case I was expecting contrast, under/overexposure rejection. Maybe even soft/oversharpen, overproccesed. But really, the last reasons I would think of were cut off and unlevel. Is it woth to appeal this one? It maybe wasn't a steady approach, but it was taken like 3 minutes after a hail storm, so there was a possibility pretty strong crosswind. And cut off? I really don't know what to say, most of my recently accepted shots from LHR were "almost wingless", and I have many more similar "cut off" shots accepted in the past.

What do you guys think?

edit: I tried to appeal, but it got rejected without any comments. Can you please point out what's actually wrong with this photo? Is it because of cut flap? Should I crop it tighter or wider? I really don't get it...

Anyone?