Bad Composition (bad framing / aircraft not centered)

[ErezS]

Dear friends,

I am really very surprised and embarrassed about this rejection.



I appealed the rejection but the appeal was rejected with a comment: ''slightly too high''.

Excuse me please, but it's doesn't seem serious.

It is very embarrassing that about so slightly, if any, the photo was rejected.

All the best,

Erez.

[Alex - Spot-This !]

Reply should have been "slightly too low" - it's only by a little but should be easy to improve

Cheers
Alex

[ErezS]

Reply should have been "slightly too low" - it's only by a little but should be easy to improve

Cheers
Alex

Alex,

Is it too high or too low? Does every person can see anything else?
I have already corrected the photo according to the previous comment, please see it:

now I'm even more embarrassed.

Maybe we'll make a compromise that it is in the center?

Is this, in all honesty, a rejection that is committed to reality?

Best regards,
Erez.

[71sbeetle]

Check this out, it helped me a lot to understand the centering on Jetphotos. I usually crop for a more "balanced" look which is lower than Jetphotos requires, but now I got used to doing it this way:

https://forums.jetphotos.com/showthread.php?52640-Processing-tips-and-tricks&p=631245&viewfull=1#post631245

[ErezS]

Check this out, it helped me a lot to understand the centering on Jetphotos. I usually crop for a more "balanced" look which is lower than Jetphotos requires, but now I got used to doing it this way:

https://forums.jetphotos.com/showthr...l=1#post631245

Thank you, I know about that, that's the way I do, but it does not contradict what I wrote above.

[B7772ADL]

Alex,

Is it too high or too low? Does every person can see anything else?
I have already corrected the photo according to the previous comment, please see it:
[ATTACH=CONFIG]7989[/ATTACH]
now I'm even more embarrassed.

Maybe we'll make a compromise that it is in the center?

Is this, in all honesty, a rejection that is committed to reality?

Best regards,
Erez.

As Alex says, it's slightly too low in the frame.

No compromise needs to be made. You can re-edit it and upload again.

[ErezS]

As Alex says, it's slightly too low in the frame.

No compromise needs to be made. You can re-edit it and upload again.

How is it in this second version above?

[B7772ADL]

This is how I try and center my photos. You can see the red lines I've inserted. I try and make sure that there's equal space above and below the fuselage to the yellow 1/3 and 2/3 lines. If anything the EasyJet is slightly high in the frame from my examples but only a little bit.

[B7772ADL]

How is it in this second version above?

Still too low. Notice how there is more space (blue sky) from the top of the fuselage to the 1/3 yellow line above and less space below the fuselage to the 2/3 yellow line below. The window line on the fuselage isn't always an exact middle point.

[ErezS]

Still too low. Notice how there is more space (blue sky) from the top of the fuselage to the 1/3 yellow line above and less space below the fuselage to the 2/3 yellow line below. The window line on the fuselage isn't always an exact middle point.

Dear James,
Thanks for your response.
I always edited the photos according to the window line on the fuselage, as it was recommended to do, but now as I understand it, you have different recommendation.

Best regards,
Erez.