Kyle McKinlay - Editing Advice

[dlowwa]

Okay. How is number 1? Thanks.

Would be rejected for noise, soft, contrast, and possibly dark/backlit.

[vcruvinel]

Okay. How is number 1? Thanks.

This one looks noisy, compressed and soft IMHO.

Better wait comments from the crew.

Cheers,

Vinicius

[KyleMcKinlay]

Okay. How is number 1? Thanks.

[LX-A343]

How are these two? I know they are 'similar', but was wondering what one, if any, is best. Thank you.

[ATTACH=CONFIG]16405[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]16406[/ATTACH]

Please choose one, thanks.

[KyleMcKinlay]

How are these two? I know they are 'similar', but was wondering what one, if any, is best. Thank you.

[KyleMcKinlay]

Ok, thanks again for the feedback. Have brightened it up and increases sharpness a tad. Can only see once screened! Thanks.

[dlowwa]

Okay. Thank you both for the feedback. Have tried a little to improve it, but maybe it's one for the 'personal collection'. How about now?

[ATTACH=CONFIG]16313[/ATTACH]

Noise is not really an issue, but would still be rejected for dark and soft.

[vcruvinel]

Okay. Thank you both for the feedback. Have tried a little to improve it, but maybe it's one for the 'personal collection'. How about now?

[ATTACH=CONFIG]16313[/ATTACH]

Kyle,

The image still noisy and soft (also dark as Dana said). The noisy is pretty visible in all the photo and I`m afraid if you apply more noise reduction the image will start to get a "plastic" appearance.

Besides it`s a really nice a/c I`m afraid it`s more for personal collection or if there is any way to make it acceptable here you will have a lot of work and I think don`t worth the effort. But it`s my personal opinion.

Better wait the crew members as always.

Cheers,

Vinicius

[KyleMcKinlay]

Okay. Thank you both for the feedback. Have tried a little to improve it, but maybe it's one for the 'personal collection'. How about now?

[dlowwa]

Hi Kyle,

This one looks noisy and soft.

Regards,

Vinicius

Also too dark.

[vcruvinel]

Hello! How is this one? Many thanks.

[ATTACH=CONFIG]16302[/ATTACH]

Hi Kyle,

This one looks noisy and soft.

Regards,

Vinicius

[KyleMcKinlay]

Hello! How is this one? Many thanks.

[KyleMcKinlay]

Great, thank you both for the feedback!

[Julian S.]

Hi,

I`m not a screener but in IMHO:

#1. Looks Ok
#2. Just a bit dark, you can increase the exposure just a little bit. But looks good about the others aspects
#3. Looks Ok
#4. Looks Ok
#5. Looks Ok

Just wait some comments from the crew too.

Regards,

Vinicius

Hi!

#1,#3,#4,#5 Agree
#2 should be OK too

Have a nice day, both

[vcruvinel]

Hi,

I`m not a screener but in IMHO:

#1. Looks Ok
#2. Just a bit dark, you can increase the exposure just a little bit. But looks good about the others aspects
#3. Looks Ok
#4. Looks Ok
#5. Looks Ok

Just wait some comments from the crew too.

Regards,

Vinicius