Matt737 - Editing Advice

[dlowwa]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]25744[/ATTACH]

Would this be accepted?

Possibly. I would be a bit concerned about oversharpening maybe hiding a bit of blur, but might be acceptable as is.

[matt737]

Would this be accepted?

[dlowwa]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]25557[/ATTACH]

Could someone take a look at this please? Wasn't too sure about the brightness and sharpening. Thanks.

Exposure should be ok, but maybe a touch too soft for 1920pix.

[matt737]

Could someone take a look at this please? Wasn't too sure about the brightness and sharpening. Thanks.

[dlowwa]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]25464[/ATTACH]

Would this be accepted?

Likely would be rejected for heat haze.

[matt737]

Would this be accepted?

[dlowwa]

I've recently been getting rejected for either soft or or overprocessed. How can I know, on my own, that an image is too soft, or too sharp/overprocessed?

Softness you're just going to have to rely on your eyes; overprocessing usually manifests itself in the form of halos (brighter areas) around objects in the frame.

[matt737]

I've recently been getting rejected for either soft or or overprocessed. How can I know, on my own, that an image is too soft, or too sharp/overprocessed?

[dlowwa]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]21946[/ATTACH]

Is this acceptable?

Would be rejected for soft, centering, overprocessed, dirty, and perhaps contrast.

[matt737]

Is this acceptable?

[pdeboer]

These are not considered similar

[matt737]

So I already have a picture of G-ZBKD in the database. I was wondering if this shot would be allowed because it is a different angle from the first, and it is a different stage of flight.



The first picture is https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/9204414.

[dlowwa]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]21103[/ATTACH]

Alright, sorry about that...hopefully this is the final version!

This image is quite soft. I suspect the original is quite soft, and the oversharpening was an attempt to cover it up. In any case, it certainly appears the quality is not there to submit at 1920pix.

[matt737]

Alright, sorry about that...hopefully this is the final version!

[dlowwa]

Does that mean if I don't sharpen it as much, it will be acceptable, or will the compression still be an issue?

Can only answer a hypothetical with another hypothetical. Maybe. Maybe not. Can only say after seeing the result.