Majky737 - Editing Advice

[Majky737]

Hi,

is this photo sharp enought?

Thank you

Marian



ps: please ignore photo on Thumbnails.

[LX-A343]

Hi,

is this photo sharp enought?

Thank you

Marian

[ATTACH=CONFIG]28524[/ATTACH]

ps: please ignore photo on Thumbnails.

Borderline soft. Maybe it passes, maybe not. The bit of noise doesn't help as well.

[Majky737]

Thank you Gerardo.

I have one more question refering to these two recent rejects:

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7566484

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7566487

Do you think that are these photos passable after better edit, or did light conditions killed them definitly?

Thank you for your opinion.

Regards
Marian

[LX-A343]

Thank you Gerardo.

I have one more question refering to these two recent rejects:

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7566484

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7566487

Do you think that are these photos passable after better edit, or did light conditions killed them definitly?

Thank you for your opinion.

Regards
Marian

In my opinion, they can be improved to an acceptable level by adjusting the curves to brighten up the aircraft without getting a uniform light grey background. That said, not all screeners wiil agree on that, so you will also need a bit of luck.

[Majky737]

In my opinion, they can be improved to an acceptable level by adjusting the curves to brighten up the aircraft without getting a uniform light grey background. That said, not all screeners wiil agree on that, so you will also need a bit of luck.

Thank you Gerardo, I understand. I made attempt to adjust contrast using curves, I think both images looks better now:




However, I take conditions into account. Maybe I will give them a chance later.

Regards
Marian

[Majky737]

Hi,

I have edited photo attached below. My question is: does the tarmac looks too overexposed? I was searchnig for ideal histogram by curves and maybe I added too much highlights.

Thank you.
Marian

[cyx323]

Hi,

I have edited photo attached below. My question is: does the tarmac looks too overexposed? I was searchnig for ideal histogram by curves and maybe I added too much highlights.

Thank you.
Marian

[ATTACH=CONFIG]28877[/ATTACH]

No, tarmac does not look overexposed. The whole pic looks a bit underexposed overall.

[Majky737]

Contrast

Hi,

I want to ask for prescreening of attached photo - especially for contrast. On Histogram, I see a gap on Midtones, but when I look on picture, it looks fine to me (so I am a little unsure about contrast).

Thank you for your time / opinion.

Marian

[dlowwa]

Hi,

I want to ask for prescreening of attached photo - especially for contrast. On Histogram, I see a gap on Midtones, but when I look on picture, it looks fine to me (so I am a little unsure about contrast).

Thank you for your time / opinion.

Marian

[ATTACH=CONFIG]29198[/ATTACH]

Should be ok, think it's just the paint job making it look like that.

[Majky737]

Hello,

I have received this reject:

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7661387

I am not fully sure what is wrong with color there, so just my guess - yellow tint?

Thank you for help
Marian

[Cleveland.Spotter]

This photo is undersaturated. That is the reason for the rejection based on what I can tell.

[dlowwa]

Hello,

I have received this reject:

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7661387

I am not fully sure what is wrong with color there, so just my guess - yellow tint?

No, there is a slight cyan cast, but acceptable in my opinion. Worth an appeal I think.

This photo is undersaturated. That is the reason for the rejection based on what I can tell.

There is no problem with the saturation.

[Cleveland.Spotter]

No, there is a slight cyan cast, but acceptable in my opinion. Worth an appeal I think.



There is no problem with the saturation.

oh. my bad.

[Majky737]

No, there is a slight cyan cast, but acceptable in my opinion. Worth an appeal I think.

Thank you. I appealed and photo is accepted now. Much appreciate your help.

This photo is undersaturated. That is the reason for the rejection based on what I can tell.

Thank you for your help

[Majky737]

Hello,

I have received this reject:

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7679106

The rejections reasons were
- Too much or too little contrast
- Horizontal unlevel

So I made a new edit. I think contrast is better, but I am still unsure about the horizont. In comparasion to rejected image, I made a little ccw rotation. Do you think that this image is acceptable as is, or need any more editing?

Thank you.
Marian