Majky737 - Editing Advice

[dlowwa]

Thank you. In your opinion, does it have chance to be accepted as is or are there any issues to fix I should focus on?

Horizon is off and it's a touch soft.

[Majky737]

Hello,

can you help me to identify soft spots on this rejected photo?

PHOTO

Thank you for your time.
Marian

[dlowwa]

Hello,

can you help me to identify soft spots on this rejected photo?

PHOTO

Thank you for your time.
Marian

Whole fuselage looks kind of soft.

[Majky737]

Hello,

today I have received 2 reject for dirty CMOS (PHOTO1, PHOTO2). So I have reviewed both photos and made a new edits trying clone out dustspots.

Can you give me quick hint if the problem with dustspots is resolved on these new edits? If no, can you help me to find dust spots still present on images?

Thank you.
Marian

[Taylor Peake]

Hello,

today I have received 2 reject for dirty CMOS (PHOTO1, PHOTO2). So I have reviewed both photos and made a new edits trying clone out dustspots.

Can you give me quick hint if the problem with dustspots is resolved on these new edits? If no, can you help me to find dust spots still present on images?

Thank you.
Marian

First shot looks like it has some halos around the tail and top of the aircraft

[dlowwa]

Hello,

today I have received 2 reject for dirty CMOS. So I have reviewed both photos and made a new edits trying clone out dustspots.

Can you give me quick hint if the problem with dustspots is resolved on these new edits? If no, can you help me to find dust spots still present on images?

First one looks ok, but multiple dust spots on second.

First shot looks like it has some halos around the tail and top of the aircraft

Ignore this advice please.

[Majky737]

Hello,

today I have received this reject:

REJECTED_PHOTO

I understand that corners are darker on equalized version of photo, but in my point of view, it is not such bad or hard to recognise. Is that really so bad to reject the photo? You know, I try to shoot in good weather to reach good contrast, sharp it and clear dust spots... after all, I get solid photo, upload it, wait of screening and then getting rejectt for vignetting... this makes me somehow frustrated. I really believed this one is fine for DB. Should I even try to fix it somehow with vignette tool in PS? Does it worth?

Marian

[dlowwa]

Hello,

today I have received this reject:

REJECTED_PHOTO

I understand that corners are darker on equalized version of photo, but in my point of view, it is not such bad or hard to recognise. Is that really so bad to reject the photo? You know, I try to shoot in good weather to reach good contrast, sharp it and clear dust spots... after all, I get solid photo, upload it, wait of screening and then getting rejectt for vignetting... this makes me somehow frustrated. I really believed this one is fine for DB. Should I even try to fix it somehow with vignette tool in PS? Does it worth?

Marian

There is minor vignetting visible. If you believe it is fine, the appeal function is there for that.

[Majky737]

There is minor vignetting visible. If you believe it is fine, the appeal function is there for that.

Thank you Dana, helped a lot. Appreciate that.

[Majky737]

Hello,

I want to ask if attached photo is acceptable due to contrast, as weather situation was complicated (however it looks like contrast is fine on this one). And one more question - if it will be rejected for compression or not (not sure about this).

Thank you
Marian

[dlowwa]

Hello,

I want to ask if attached photo is acceptable due to contrast, as weather situation was complicated (however it looks like contrast is fine on this one). And one more question - if it will be rejected for compression or not (not sure about this).

Contrast ok for me, but soft and yes sky a bit blotchy.

[Majky737]

Hello,

I need a little hint on this REJECTED IMAGE - how to fix contrast on this one? Is it too strong or to weak?

Thank you
Marian

[dlowwa]

Hello,

I need a little hint on this REJECTED IMAGE - how to fix contrast on this one? Is it too strong or to weak?

Thank you
Marian

A bit too strong.

[Majky737]

A bit too strong.

Thank you. Is it somehow better on new attached edit, or not much difference at all?

Marian

[dlowwa]

Thank you. Is it somehow better on new attached edit, or not much difference at all?

Don't see a huge difference, tbh.