Majky737 - Editing Advice

[Oojiflip]

Hello,

today I have received 2 reject for dirty CMOS (PHOTO1, PHOTO2). So I have reviewed both photos and made a new edits trying clone out dustspots.

Can you give me quick hint if the problem with dustspots is resolved on these new edits? If no, can you help me to find dust spots still present on images?

Thank you.
Marian

First shot looks like it has some halos around the tail and top of the aircraft

[Majky737]

Hello,

today I have received 2 reject for dirty CMOS (PHOTO1, PHOTO2). So I have reviewed both photos and made a new edits trying clone out dustspots.

Can you give me quick hint if the problem with dustspots is resolved on these new edits? If no, can you help me to find dust spots still present on images?

Thank you.
Marian

[dlowwa]

Hello,

can you help me to identify soft spots on this rejected photo?

PHOTO

Thank you for your time.
Marian

Whole fuselage looks kind of soft.

[Majky737]

Hello,

can you help me to identify soft spots on this rejected photo?

PHOTO

Thank you for your time.
Marian

[dlowwa]

Thank you. In your opinion, does it have chance to be accepted as is or are there any issues to fix I should focus on?

Horizon is off and it's a touch soft.

[Majky737]

Close, but not quite backlit.

Thank you. In your opinion, does it have chance to be accepted as is or are there any issues to fix I should focus on?

[dlowwa]

Hello jetPhotos crew,

can you help me to determine if attached photo should be rejected for backlit or not? I am somehow unable to say if tail is on it's own shadow or not.

Close, but not quite backlit.

[Majky737]

Hello jetPhotos crew,

can you help me to determine if attached photo should be rejected for backlit or not? I am somehow unable to say if tail is on it's own shadow or not.

Thank you for your comments.
Marian

[dlowwa]

Hello,

I have received this reject:

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=11025098

I made another edit of another image from same photos batch hoping to resolve compression issue.

Is the new edit acceptable in therms of compression, colors and contrast?

Rejected (and new) image was fine for me in terms of color, but both show some heat haze.

[Majky737]

Hello,

I have received this reject:

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=11025098

I made another edit of another image from same photos batch hoping to resolve compression issue.

Is the new edit acceptable in therms of compression, colors and contrast?

Thank you for your time.

Kind regards
Marian

[dlowwa]

Hello screeners,

today I have received photo reject due undersharpened and noise HERE

I have added some extra sharpening and some noise reduction as well. Can you give me hint if there is any improvement visible on new edit and if it is maybe acceptable as - is now?

Still lots of soft areas. Not sure the quality is there to make this workable.

[Majky737]

Hello screeners,

today I have received photo reject due undersharpened and noise HERE

I have added some extra sharpening and some noise reduction as well. Can you give me hint if there is any improvement visible on new edit and if it is maybe acceptable as - is now?

Thank you for your time.
Marian

[dlowwa]

I think that it is ok, as intentions of this question were to find noise areas, reprocess and queue again.

However, I think problem was related to sky area, so I have applied some more noise reduction filter there. Can you prescreen new edit attached below?

Sorry, I think I meant to post that reply in a different thread..though I think it mostly applies here. Wouldn't have been a rejection for me, but I can kind of see why it might have been for someone else. Newer version slightly soft, but also ok for me.

[Majky737]

Borderline for me, but enough for a rejection for the two screeners who screened it. Not much chance of a successful appeal.

I think that it is ok, as intentions of this question were to find noise areas, reprocess and queue again.

However, I think problem was related to sky area, so I have applied some more noise reduction filter there. Can you prescreen new edit attached below?

Thank you.

[dlowwa]

Hi,

I have received this reject for Noise/grain:

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=10472541

In what areas of photo is noise visible? Will selective noise reduction help in this case?

Borderline for me, but enough for a rejection for the two screeners who screened it. Not much chance of a successful appeal.