aceriana - editing advice

[aceriana]

Hello
Are these two photos OK for upload as photos at dawn?




Thank you and regards

[aceriana]

As it seems, you appealed it already. I'll pass on commenting the photo here.

Roger on that. Hope the appeal goes through.
Thank you

[LX-A343]

Hello
Can someone help me with this rejection? Exactly where is the JPG compression?

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7152603

Thank you and regards

As it seems, you appealed it already. I'll pass on commenting the photo here.

[aceriana]

Hello
Can someone help me with this rejection? Exactly where is the JPG compression?

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7152603

Thank you and regards

[dlowwa]

The problem is not your question, it’s your attitude. You can choose to be confrontational if you wish (up to a point where I may just close this thread), but doing so is probably not the best way to elicit a response from a volunteer crew who have no obligation to spend their time here and can choose to simply ignore such hassles. You’re expecting full explanations and resolutions to every single issue you encounter, but that simply may not be possible for a variety of reasons.

Feel free to continue posting your questions, but please be aware that your attitude dictates how likely it is that you will get a response from the crew.

[aceriana]

Tony

Please understand.
As I have explained. My image is identical just from a different angle to an image I saw accepted. I look at images on the database and try to copy the cropping.
Can you please explain why that one was accepted and mine rejected? Was the accepted image accepted by mistake as sometimes happens.
That is all I ask. Often the explations to improve and solve are scarce here. Generating more doubts and questions on my behalf.

[777MAN]

HELLO??? My question has been in queue here in the forum for several days...threads are answered but no answer here.... please can someone kindly asnwer my cropping question?

Hi, posting/embedding other peoples images within your own 'rant' doesn't help and is bad form.

stick to your image for comment - your image is badly cropped. I didn't screen it, but would reject. Not sure what you are looking for here?

A senior screener has offered lots of advice.

[aceriana]

Hello Dana

Thank you for your patience.
I am sorry for being so harsh - but I had a terrible day yesterday - not a good excuse anyway.

As for the EGYPTAIR (dustspots) I opened an appeal and hope it gets resolved.
As for the TURKISH (cropped) please check out this photo. It is the same exact angle and crop

https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/9243066

When I try something out of my ordinary standard editing, I normally look around and see if that example exists. If I find a few samples I come to the conclusion, this type of editing must be acceptable.
As you can see this D-ABUC is cropped exactly like mine - just that it is inflight and from the opposite side of view.
Do I need to flag something so it is identified as close up?

HELLO??? My question has been in queue here in the forum for several days...threads are answered but no answer here.... please can someone kindly asnwer my cropping question?

[aceriana]

Hello Dana

Thank you for your patience.
I am sorry for being so harsh - but I had a terrible day yesterday - not a good excuse anyway.

As for the EGYPTAIR (dustspots) I opened an appeal and hope it gets resolved.
As for the TURKISH (cropped) please check out this photo. It is the same exact angle and crop

https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/9243066

When I try something out of my ordinary standard editing, I normally look around and see if that example exists. If I find a few samples I come to the conclusion, this type of editing must be acceptable.
As you can see this D-ABUC is cropped exactly like mine - just that it is inflight and from the opposite side of view.
Do I need to flag something so it is identified as close up?

Anybody can check my doubt of the cropping vs the D-ABUC I used as reference?

[dlowwa]

The appeal was rejected because of: bad contrast

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7146296

Can someone please explain where the bad contrast is?

Related to your color issues. I can see it (weak contrast), but would have been borderline acceptable for me. I've removed the cyan cast and boosted the contrast on the right side here:



Pretty sure something like that would have been acceptable to all.

[aceriana]

The appeal was rejected because of: bad contrast

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7146296

Can someone please explain where the bad contrast is?

[aceriana]

Hello Dana

Thank you for your patience.
I am sorry for being so harsh - but I had a terrible day yesterday - not a good excuse anyway.

As for the EGYPTAIR (dustspots) I opened an appeal and hope it gets resolved.
As for the TURKISH (cropped) please check out this photo. It is the same exact angle and crop

https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/9243066

When I try something out of my ordinary standard editing, I normally look around and see if that example exists. If I find a few samples I come to the conclusion, this type of editing must be acceptable.
As you can see this D-ABUC is cropped exactly like mine - just that it is inflight and from the opposite side of view.
Do I need to flag something so it is identified as close up?

[dlowwa]

Hey Fellas

This photo has been screened and viewed before with ONE rejection motif. Bad color.
That has been correctly fixed. Now you see dust spots? Where? Is this the new tactic of rejecting my photos each time I re-upload them? One new error each time?
https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7146296

Don't see anything that would obviously be identifiable as a dust spot.

And then another favorite of mine. Part of aircraft cutoff. Where is the problem? There are other photos like this. Why are my croppings 95% time rejected?
https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7146303

Stabilizer is cut. A subjective thing, but most prefer not cutting part of the aircraft unless there is a reason (i.e. close up, etc..)

[aceriana]

Hey Fellas
I am losing my patience here

This photo has been screened and viewed before with ONE rejection motif. Bad color.
That has been correctly fixed. Now you see dust spots? Where? Is this the new tactic of rejecting my photos each time I re-upload them? One new error each time?
https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7146296

And then another favorite of mine. Part of aircraft cutoff. Where is the problem? There are other photos like this. Why are my croppings 95% time rejected?
https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7146303

[aceriana]

Hey Dana
Is it taboo if you put me in touch with the other spotter who has my same color perception problem? Perhaps we can find a solution together rather then me alone vs. the imaginary windmills like Don Quijote.