Pre-Screen

[Wordpress]

Thanks for the opinions Jullian! May I also have some feedback on this photo?

[Julian S.]

Thanks for the opinions Jullian! May I also have some feedback on this photo?

Hi!

That Picture is too soft for me personally.

[Wordpress]

Thank you for the feedback again Julian. May I also have some opinions on these photos?

[Julian S.]

Hi!

UA 757 is too soft and have contrast issues.
DL 757 is very borderline for oversharpen and overexposed/contrast - i would lift the shadows a bit and reduce the lights..only a bit to reduce the contrast
AA 319 should be OK, verticals seems leveled
DL 757 is soft and similar to Image #2
AZ 330 is also soft in the nose section and probably a bit too noisy

[Wordpress]

Thanks for the feedback once again. How about this new photo and the re-edit?

[Julian S.]

Both are soft, sorry!

[Wordpress]

No problem. How about these?

[dlowwa]

No problem. How about these?

1-3 overprocessed/dirty/contrast
4 cropping/ratio
5 overprocessed

[Wordpress]

1-3 overprocessed/dirty/contrast
4 cropping/ratio
5 overprocessed

Thank you for thee swift respnse. May I ask what dirty means? Also I know the rules about re-edits are a bit hit or miss, but would these be okay now?

[dlowwa]

Thank you for thee swift respnse. May I ask what dirty means?

Dust spot(s).

Also I know the rules about re-edits are a bit hit or miss, but would these be okay now?

1. ok for me
2. borderline soft

[Wordpress]

Alright, just found out how to check for the dust spots, and I re-edited some of the photos. How do they look now?

[dlowwa]

Alright, just found out how to check for the dust spots, and I re-edited some of the photos. How do they look now?

1. overprocessed
2. ok
3. overprocessed

[Wordpress]

Thanks for the opinions on those, no idea why I resent the Aeroflot, but anyway, I'd like some opinions on this photo.

[dlowwa]

Thanks for the opinions on those, no idea why I resent the Aeroflot, but anyway, I'd like some opinions on this photo.

Potential issues with softness and contrast, although would be acceptable for me.

[Wordpress]

Do you think this re-edit would be more acceptable?