Editing Advice - Arnold Aaron

[ajaaron]

Can I also check there are no more dust spots on this equalized image...

the black blob is where I've removed some big spots, but I just want to check this is now acceptable. The spots themselves are not visible on the final image as can be seen below.

[ajaaron]

Can I check I have the contrast right on this one....

[LX-A343]

Can I just check the centering is ok on this Easyjet... I believe all else in check...

[ATTACH=CONFIG]21572[/ATTACH]
Thank you.

Centering is OK. But the photo is soft and suffers from heat distortion

[ajaaron]

Can I just check the centering is ok on this Easyjet... I believe all else in check...


Thank you.

[Alex - Spot-This !]

Hi,
Easyjet has no chance of being accepted due to the poor contrast on a very common plane.

Delta should be ok

Regards
Alex

[ajaaron]

Can I ask for your opinion on this Easyjet shot, taken at Manchester in far from ideal conditions...done the best i can with the editing....



and....

is this Delta A330 crop/motive acceptable?

[Alex - Spot-This !]

Hi,
If you look at the sky, you'll actually see squares all over the place which are due to compression. Probably caused by some noise reduction or any filters applied to sky.

Regards
Alex

[ajaaron]

Good morning - I've just had this rejected for JPG compression artefacts - rather odd because I've edited straight off the original RAW file - in any case, would you be able to highlight where the artefacts are showing on this photo? - Also, I omitted to complete the date properly for the photograph - in such cases would I need to re-upload and join the queue again, or can I edit/complete the date and appeal?

Here's the photo.. PHOTO ID: 7087454



Thank you.

[777MAN]

Is the contrast ok on this Embraer?

Any other issues? Thank you.

[ATTACH=CONFIG]21441[/ATTACH]

Also can i check the crop is acceptable on this VS A330.

[ATTACH=CONFIG]21449[/ATTACH]

1) Needs to be intended upload size for pre screening (4408pix long side atm)
2) Crop should be ok, could be tighter. visible noise and CMOS.

Regards T

[ajaaron]

Is the contrast ok on this Embraer?

Any other issues? Thank you.



Also can i check the crop is acceptable on this VS A330.

[dlowwa]

Thanks for the quick response...would these fare any better?

[ATTACH=CONFIG]21380[/ATTACH]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]21381[/ATTACH]

1. borderline contrast
2. soft, heat haze, contrast

[ajaaron]

Thanks for the quick response...would these fare any better?

[LX-A343]

I know conditions in this are undesirable, but I have seen some pic in overcast conditions....nevertheless this UA 777 my best shot...any chance?

[ATTACH=CONFIG]21379[/ATTACH]

I wouldn't upload it, slim chances of being accepted.

[ajaaron]

I know conditions in this are undesirable, but I have seen some pic in overcast conditions....nevertheless this UA 777 my best shot...any chance?

[dlowwa]

Can I just check the framing is good on this one. Also I don't see any halos. Please confirm. Thank you.

[ATTACH=CONFIG]21354[/ATTACH]

Framing fine and no halos, but other issues.