Editing Advice - Arnold Aaron

[ajaaron]

hi, Just had this one rejected for being unsharpened, and over-processed. However, Im having trouble seeing where there are halos/over-processing...could you kindly point them out please.

[dlowwa]

Is this framing acceptable, or is it classed as being 'cut-off'....?

[ATTACH=CONFIG]26357[/ATTACH]

Framing is acceptable. Other issues present, however.

[Michael Rodeback]

I'd leave the entire gear door in if you can. Not sure if the gear door alone would cause a rejection though.

[ajaaron]

Is this framing acceptable, or is it classed as being 'cut-off'....?

[dlowwa]

and the positioning of this A320 in the frame - tried to centre it as much as possible - passable? thanks.

[ATTACH=CONFIG]26179[/ATTACH]

Framing ok, top of fuselage looks almost blown out.

[ajaaron]

and the positioning of this A320 in the frame - tried to centre it as much as possible - passable? thanks.

[dlowwa]

Would this nose shot be acceptable? - i.e. is the angle/inclination of the nose ok? MAny thanks...up to 65 photos now - 6 months ago I was getting rejection after rejection....those of you new to this, just stick with it, with time you will learn how to edit photos to perfection!

[ATTACH=CONFIG]26160[/ATTACH]

The angle does look a bit odd, but the crop should be ok.

[ajaaron]

Would this nose shot be acceptable? - i.e. is the angle/inclination of the nose ok? MAny thanks...up to 65 photos now - 6 months ago I was getting rejection after rejection....those of you new to this, just stick with it, with time you will learn how to edit photos to perfection!

[dlowwa]

Is this motive/position of aircraft in frame acceptable? - Obviously wanting to include the road as the motive.

[ATTACH=CONFIG]26032[/ATTACH]

Doesn't really work for me, too much space and off-centering to justify it.

[ajaaron]

Is this motive/position of aircraft in frame acceptable? - Obviously wanting to include the road as the motive.

[dlowwa]

Can I check if this crop is acceptable?

[ATTACH=CONFIG]25641[/ATTACH]

Looks unbalanced to me.

[ajaaron]

Can I check if this crop is acceptable?

[dlowwa]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]25605[/ATTACH]

Can I just check that the crop is acceptable on this CX 777? Many thanks. Thoroughly enjoying this site and the quest to add photos - most addictive.

Borderline for the crop, but also soft.

[ajaaron]

Can I just check that the crop is acceptable on this CX 777? Many thanks. Thoroughly enjoying this site and the quest to add photos - most addictive.

[dlowwa]

ok - how about these shots? - any issues here?

Yes.

1. vignetting, possibly horizon, but can't really tell
2. soft, color, horizon