Pre Screening Advice - Robbie Mathieson

[VH-ROB]

Hi Robbie,
Sorry but those have too poor light to be acceptable in terms of contrast, they look over edited too (too much noise reduction)

Kind Regards
Alex

Thought as much, thanks Alex

[Alex - Spot-This !]

Hi all, can I get some pre-screening on these 5 please. Lighting wasn't the best, thought I'd better ask for a second opinion before putting in the queue. Thanks, Robbie.

Hi Robbie,
Sorry but those have too poor light to be acceptable in terms of contrast, they look over edited too (too much noise reduction)

Kind Regards
Alex

[VH-ROB]

Hi all, can I get some pre-screening on these 5 please. Lighting wasn't the best, thought I'd better ask for a second opinion before putting in the queue. Thanks, Robbie.

[VH-ROB]

No worries, Thanks Dana.

[dlowwa]

Hi All, can I get some pre-screening on this one too please. I'm a bit worried about contrast, and also the fence. Thanks, Robbie

This would be rejected for obstruction.

[VH-ROB]

Hi All, can I get some pre-screening on this one too please. I'm a bit worried about contrast, and also the fence. Thanks, Robbie

[VH-ROB]

Would be rejected for dark/blurry/noisy.

Thought as much, thanks Dana

[dlowwa]

Hi guys, can I get some feedback regarding this one please, I feel it may be rejected for quality but want a second opinion before I put it in the queue. Thanks, Robbie
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25542[/ATTACH]

Would be rejected for dark/blurry/noisy.

[VH-ROB]

Hi guys, can I get some feedback regarding this one please, I feel it may be rejected for quality but want a second opinion before I put it in the queue. Thanks, Robbie

[VH-ROB]

I'd have considered your friend's image to be borderline to start with, and his is a much better edit, so there you go. Yours is also soft, besides the contrast issue, just to be aware.

Okay, no worries. Thanks Dana

[dlowwa]

Can I get some advice please on https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7353380. To me, the contrast looks fine, and looks very similar to photo id 9341828, which was taken by a friend who was only around 5 metres away from me. Thanks, Robbie

I'd have considered your friend's image to be borderline to start with, and his is a much better edit, so there you go. Yours is also soft, besides the contrast issue, just to be aware.

[VH-ROB]

Can I get some advice please on https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7353380. To me, the contrast looks fine, and looks very similar to photo id 9341828, which was taken by a friend who was only around 5 metres away from me. Thanks, Robbie

[VH-ROB]

I would appeal it, explaining the difference in livery between the images.

Appealed. And accepted. Thanks for your help Dana.

[dlowwa]

Thanks Dana, that's actually quite a good idea, I'll bear that in mind for future uploads. Regarding the one that was rejected, should I appeal it, or upload it into the queue again? Many Thanks, Robbie

I would appeal it, explaining the difference in livery between the images.

[VH-ROB]

If there is a (permanent) difference in livery, then it shouldn't be considered similar. Might be a good idea to include a note to the screeners next time when uploading such images (ones that appear similar at first glance), clarifying how the livery has been updated.

Thanks Dana, that's actually quite a good idea, I'll bear that in mind for future uploads. Regarding the one that was rejected, should I appeal it, or upload it into the queue again? Many Thanks, Robbie