john1024 - prescreening request / editing advice

[john1024]

Thanks for the fast replay. Very helpful.

[john1024]

Dear JP Forum
I would like to ask you about following picture:
Is there any issue?

I'm not sure about there might be an issue with vignetting.

thanks in advance for your help.

All the best, John.

[dlowwa]

Dear JP Forum
I would like to ask you about following picture:
Is there any issue?

I'm not sure about there might be an issue with vignetting.

There is a little bit of vignetting visible yes, but wouldn't be an issue for me.

[john1024]

Dear JP Forum

I got rejection to cut of part of the airplane. My intension was to cut part of, but still not get the rule. what do i have to frame, I can't find any logic in that topic and got lot of rejection.

please help me.

thanks in advance.

john

[dlowwa]

Dear JP Forum

I got rejection to cut of part of the airplane. My intension was to cut part of, but still not get the rule. what do i have to frame, I can't find any logic in that topic and got lot of rejection.

please help me.

thanks in advance.

john

A bit awkward on the right side. Needs to be tighter, or to show the whole aircraft.

[john1024]

Thanks dlowwa for the quick answer. I was paying attention to not cut of the wheel.
For me there would be two other 'crop points', see attachment. 1 'wing' or 2 'root of the wing'.
which is acceptebl, and why?

[dlowwa]

Thanks dlowwa for the quick answer. I was paying attention to not cut of the wheel.
For me there would be two other 'crop points', see attachment. 1 'wing' or 2 'root of the wing'.
which is acceptebl, and why?

I'd go with 1 if it were me.

[john1024]

Dear Forum

I'm a bit out of ideas: I got for following picture rejection: due to Over Processed / Bad postprocessing and Too much noise or grain

What I do not understand is what I did wrong: I shoot all the time with iso 100, and I do only a minor adjustments in lightroom. Brightness (+0.85), contrast +4, and sharpening. I do not understand the noise and what is overprocessed.

Thanks for any hint.

[dlowwa]

Dear Forum

I'm a bit out of ideas: I got for following picture rejection: due to Over Processed / Bad postprocessing and Too much noise or grain

What I do not understand is what I did wrong: I shoot all the time with iso 100, and I do only a minor adjustments in lightroom. Brightness (+0.85), contrast +4, and sharpening. I do not understand the noise and what is overprocessed.

Thanks for any hint.

Editing halos, and lots of noise in the shadows (probably from whatever caused the halos). Also soft imho.

[john1024]

Thanks a lot for your help and ffedback.

What about following?

Thanks in advance for your answer. All the best, john.

[dlowwa]

Thanks a lot for your help and ffedback.

What about following?

Thanks in advance for your answer. All the best, john.

Borderline soft. Processing and noise seem to be under control.

[john1024]

Dear JP comunity
Want you to ask for following picture: It was taken during heavy snowfall (visible in the lights for the fine). The Iso was at 160, but due to the snow looks like heavy noise.
Ismthat acceptable? The plane stands for some minutes, so the pictuer was taken with low ISO and long expouser.

Thanks in advance for feedback. John

[dlowwa]

Dear JP comunity
Want you to ask for following picture: It was taken during heavy snowfall (visible in the lights for the fine). The Iso was at 160, but due to the snow looks like heavy noise.
Ismthat acceptable? The plane stands for some minutes, so the pictuer was taken with low ISO and long expouser.

Thanks in advance for feedback. John

Softness/contrast/poor light would just as big issues, if not bigger than the apparent 'noise'.

[john1024]

Thanks a lot dlowwa.

As I understod I did a few adjustments and also 1920.
Any chance? Personally Iike the snowstorm and quite proud that I was able to catch under that (almost) impsssible situation that special. That's why I ask for advice.

Thanks in advance also for all of your great work.

All the best, John

[dlowwa]

Thanks a lot dlowwa.

As I understod I did a few adjustments and also 1920.
Any chance? Personally Iike the snowstorm and quite proud that I was able to catch under that (almost) impsssible situation that special. That's why I ask for advice.

0% chance at this resolution. Soft/blurry and some noise (not snow).