new member prescreening

[bwn]

[dlowwa]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]23921[/ATTACH]

Got a few new images

[ATTACH=CONFIG]23922[/ATTACH] [ATTACH=CONFIG]23923[/ATTACH] [ATTACH=CONFIG]23924[/ATTACH]

These images are dark, noisy, dirty, poorly centered, soft/blurry, and except for the first backlit. The former two issues are not fixable, so please do not bother trying to make new edits for here.

[bwn]

It might have a few dust spots, but other than that is this one ok?

[bwn]

I think I may have fixed the backlitness here

[LX-A343]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]24015[/ATTACH]

I think I may have fixed the backlitness here

Backlight is impossible to be fixed.

[bwn]

Also, is this one fixable?

[bwn]

Also, can I fix this one?

[bwn]

I attempted to remove the compression, how are they now?

[dlowwa]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]24220[/ATTACH]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]24221[/ATTACH]

I attempted to remove the compression, how are they now?

I'll offer to give advice one more time, but only under the condition that you 1) follow said advice and 2) post the rejections you disagree with here for advice before appealing. If you can do that, I'm willing to continue giving feedback. If not, which of course is totally at your discretion, I won't be replying to your requests any more.

[bwn]

I'll offer to give advice one more time, but only under the condition that you 1) follow said advice and 2) post the rejections you disagree with here for advice before appealing. If you can do that, I'm willing to continue giving feedback. If not, which of course is totally at your discretion, I won't be replying to your requests any more.

Ok , I'm not sure why you're angry with me, as I feel like I am doing as you say. I obviously want your help. Can you please what I'm doing wrong so I can correct it

[dlowwa]

Ok , I'm not sure why you're angry with me, as I feel like I am doing as you say. I obviously want your help. Can you please what I'm doing wrong so I can correct it

1) I'm not angry.
2) You're not doing anything wrong. It's just when I tell you an image like this is soft



but you upload it anyway, and more importantly appeal it after it gets rejected for soft (which of course you are allowed to do), I don't see much point it offering more advice if said advice is just going to be disregarded.

[bwn]

Hi,
Sorry I didn't respond earlier. When you said that the horizon was acceptable, I interpreted that as the whole image being acceptable. That is also why I appealed, because I thought you had given it the ok. I'm sorry for the miscommunication. With that said, can you take a look at these?

[dlowwa]

Hi,
Sorry I didn't respond earlier. When you said that the horizon was acceptable, I interpreted that as the whole image being acceptable. That is also why I appealed, because I thought you had given it the ok. I'm sorry for the miscommunication. With that said, can you take a look at these?
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25046[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]25047[/ATTACH]

Both of these images are quite soft and lack contrast. I am not sure that they are fixable.

[bwn]

I realize that the 717 might not be workable, but how's this? I did the smart sharpen by 200% and increased contrast

[dlowwa]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]25062[/ATTACH]

I realize that the 717 might not be workable, but how's this? I did the smart sharpen by 200% and increased contrast

This would be rejected for soft and contrast.