dxtrx-Prescreening request / Editing advice

[dlowwa]

I've tried many times, but the corners of one of the pictures were either brighter or darker than the center, so I just switched it to another one.So are all five photos acceptable this time? (Some of these still have light dark corners, but I think they are barely visible in normal mode.) Thanks!
[ATTACH=CONFIG]24357[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]24358[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]24359[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]24360[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]24361[/ATTACH]

Yes, slight vignetting on 2, 4, 5. The last two also a bit low in the frame. By cropping some of them tighter, you'd also be cropping out a good part of the vignetting as well..

[dxtrx]

Yes, slight vignetting on 2, 4, 5. The last two also a bit low in the frame. By cropping some of them tighter, you'd also be cropping out a good part of the vignetting as well..

I cropped No.2,4,5 again. Looks better this time?

[dlowwa]

I cropped No.2,4,5 again. Looks better this time?[ATTACH=CONFIG]24403[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]24404[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]24405[/ATTACH]

These would be acceptable for me.

[dxtrx]

These would be acceptable for me.

Thanks！With regards please prescreen these 5 photos. They were taken on the same day as the previous ones.

[dlowwa]

Thanks！With regards please prescreen these 5 photos. They were taken on the same day as the previous ones.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]24419[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]24420[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]24421[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]24422[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]24423[/ATTACH]

1. ok
2. overprocessed
3. vignetting
4-5 overprocessed

[dxtrx]

1. ok
2. overprocessed
3. vignetting
4-5 overprocessed

Thanks for the comments. For No.3 I will do some adjustments later. As for No.2,4,5 I’ve just read the Upload Guidelines again, but I only do some corrections for dark corners and white balance from the RAW files, so maybe I’m supposed to lower their contrast and exposure?

[dlowwa]

Thanks for the comments. For No.3 I will do some adjustments later. As for No.2,4,5 I’ve just read the Upload Guidelines again, but I only do some corrections for dark corners and white balance from the RAW files, so maybe I’m supposed to lower their contrast and exposure?

You have overcorrected for the dark corners on the overprocessed images. There is a bright ring around the edges of the frame that should not be there.

[dxtrx]

You have overcorrected for the dark corners on the overprocessed images. There is a bright ring around the edges of the frame that should not be there.

Oh I just noticed that. Sorry I put too much attention on the aircraft itself.

[dxtrx]

How about them this time? Much appreciate.

[dlowwa]

How about them this time? Much appreciate.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]24432[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]24433[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]24434[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]24435[/ATTACH]

#2 a bit low in the frame, but I don't see overprocessing as being an issue any more.

[dxtrx]

#2 a bit low in the frame, but I don't see overprocessing as being an issue any more.

Thank you.

[dxtrx]

Hi. I'd like to know if this photo will be rejectted for " Cut Off ". Thanks!

[dlowwa]

Hi. I'd like to know if this photo will be rejectted for " Cut Off ". Thanks![ATTACH=CONFIG]24454[/ATTACH]

Likely, yes.

[dxtrx]

Likely, yes.

Ok I cropped it again. But I feel the left wing takes up too much place of the picture...

[dlowwa]

Ok I cropped it again. But I feel the left wing takes up too much place of the picture...
[ATTACH=CONFIG]24455[/ATTACH]

Corp is fine, but would be rejected for overprocessed and dirty.