Bapt0708: Pre-screening/How to do a better editing ?

[LX-A343]

Ok so this image is dead for jetphoto because a part of the elevator is cut off in the original picture, but i would like to know the cropping ratio, it's because if i take another ratio the fence is really visible, is it a problem or not ? this is the original picture:
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25555[/ATTACH]
i changed the color profile in my settings i was in e-Srgb and not Srgb

The chopped off elevator is a killer.

[bapt0708]

Ok so i took an other picture from this spot:

Normaly this one compare to the other one has good croping ratio, centering, the good color profile; and any part of the plane is cut off.
May i have your general opinion for this one ?

[dlowwa]

Ok so i took an other picture from this spot:
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25570[/ATTACH]
Normaly this one compare to the other one has good croping ratio, centering, the good color profile; and any part of the plane is cut off.
May i have your general opinion for this one ?

Obstructed and backlit.

[bapt0708]

Ok thank you, two questions for you:
-Is the first obstructed by the vegetation or is it something else ?
-How can i see that a picture is backlit, and how can i fix it ?

[dlowwa]

Ok thank you, two questions for you:
-Is the first obstructed by the vegetation or is it something else ?

Vegetation.

-How can i see that a picture is backlit, and how can i fix it ?

If the tail is fully in shadow, then we consider it backlit. It can't be fixed.

[bapt0708]

If the tail is fully in shadow, then we consider it backlit. It can't be fixed.

Ok so normally this one isn't backlit and is it obstructed by the vegetation (around the wheels) or not ?
is it acceptable ?

[dlowwa]

Ok so normally this one isn't backlit and is it obstructed by the vegetation (around the wheels) or not ?
is it acceptable ?
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25586[/ATTACH]

Backlit no, but obstruction likely, since it looks like it could have been avoided with better positioning/timing.

[bapt0708]

Ok so i have a doubt on this one:

Maybe also obstructed but the vegetation is not really on any part of the plane.

A little question for an other one, is this angle acceptable or not ?


And a pre-screening for this two please:

[dlowwa]

Ok so i have a doubt on this one:
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25592[/ATTACH]
Maybe also obstructed but the vegetation is not really on any part of the plane.

Obstruction not an issue, but contrast is borderline.

A little question for an other one, is this angle acceptable or not ?
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25593[/ATTACH]

This would be rejected for Cut Off, among other things.

And a pre-screening for this two please:
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25594[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25595[/ATTACH]

1. borderline contrast
2. soft, dark

[bapt0708]

I reworked the three is it better ?

[bapt0708]

Hello ! may i have a pree-screening of this one too please ?

[dlowwa]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]25619[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]25620[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]25621[/ATTACH]
I reworked the three is it better ?

1. borderline contrast
2-3 contrast

Hello ! may i have a pree-screening of this one too please ?
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25653[/ATTACH]

Contrast, borderline soft.

[bapt0708]

Thank dlowwa I reworked all of them following your previous tips for the contrat. is it better now ?



i have a doubt on this one maybe it's backlit ?

[dlowwa]

Thank dlowwa I reworked all of them following your previous tips for the contrat. is it better now ?
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25659[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25660[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25661[/ATTACH]
i have a doubt on this one maybe it's backlit ?
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25662[/ATTACH]

1. borderline oversharpened
2. borderline dark/contrast
3. contrast. not fixable.
4. contrast

[bapt0708]

Hello sorry for the late response i was out for few days.
i reworked all the 3 pictures which can be fixable.



Is it better for the contrast for the 2 and 3,
if not may i have an indication too much or too little ? would be really appreciated to make my point.
thank you.