OK, what's wrong with these pictures?

[egll]

My thoughts?.....

I think that you should quit complaining about things that don't matter, I also think that you are pretty mean to publicly criticise other peoples work, particularly the pictures from AirMauwie that you passed judgement on. Please let us all see the pictures that you are referring to-display them here so everyone can see them, I've already seen them and I think that the re-upload that AirMauwie submitted is way better than either of your shots.


"I appealed and it got accepted of course"

"Accepted of course"

That's an attitude you need to lose straight away, noone has the right to have pictures accepted here as a matter of course-even screeners get shots rejected sometimes, as do many of the big name photographers. Switch off that TV and start learning some humility and some more photographic skills, maybe then you might be a little bit closer to being the armchair screener you think you are.

We would think a lot more of you if you showed the pictures you are talking about.


Matt

[Crazy764]

I'm sure MauwieAir will have a nice response to this.
He is in the forums.

[JeffinDEN]

Matt!

Outstanding. I can't say stuff like that anymore....

But you can!

[Crazy764]

I can't say stuff like that anymore....

Why not?

[egll]

It's not half of what I wish I could say


Matt

[xiphias]

My thoughts?.....

Like I said, just ran into them and that's why I posted the them, no personal offense to the photographer, he makes some nice shots. Just the fact that those 2 got accepted just stunned me. I guess that doubles are only checked at upload time and not after a while. Maybe idea to create function that lest photographers delete his images. Could be tricky with the database though.

As for the ofcourse, it's just that sure they got accepeted once it was clear that the shots were different.

Sorry if I offended anyone, that was not the intention.

Cheers,

[fireguy274]

?

I would first like to say hi to everyone. I am new here about three or four weeks.....I have a questions for Xiphias. I was wondering after all the bashing you have done of the screening on here and peoples photos that you thought were inferior to yours, how do you think this will tip the scales on any of your photos you upload in the future that might be say borderline or questionable? I mean If I were a screener and I came to a photo and I thought it was borderline and saw your name on it I would start laughing as I clicked the reject button. To quote you "no offense" .....Nice to meet you all....Artie Caissie

[SWA733Captain]

Re: ?

I mean If I were a screener and I came to a photo and I thought it was borderline and saw your name on it I would start laughing as I clicked the reject button.

Yeah that's about the size if what's probably gonna happen to him.