User Profile

[dlowwa]

Would still be a color rejection for me....

[dlowwa]

Contras a bit weak, some compression visible, and tail is soft/blurry....

[dlowwa]

Would not be acceptable for me....

[dlowwa]

There's something below the front fuselage where it looks like you've attempted to remove some dust, but other than that, don't see anything that should cause an issue....

[dlowwa]

Halos are gone and centering looks ok, but this version is soft, a bit yellow, and still lacks contrast....

[dlowwa]

You can appeal, but remember that my opinion is that only, and doesn't represent the whole crew. If you decide to appeal, please make your case on its own merits, not 'screener x in the forum said I should appeal'....

[dlowwa]

Maybe a touch soft on the first, but would be ok for me....

[dlowwa]

No, it would have been rejected for cut off due to the awkward crop of the tail....

[dlowwa]

Looks acceptable to me....

[dlowwa]

Still very borderline for contrast, and other issues. Due to the weak light, not sure this one will be fixable....

[dlowwa]

Hi, please read #2:

https://forums.jetphotos.com/forum/a...ning-from-crew...

[dlowwa]

I see three big issues with this image: centering, contrast, and processing. It is a bit too low in the frame, contrast is weak, and there are editing halos. It could possibly be fixable with a better edit....

[dlowwa]

Neither centering nor processing should be an issue with this image, though you will always have a better chance at 1280pix....

[dlowwa]

Borderline on the first, but shouldn't be an issue on the second....

[dlowwa]

Last time I'll remind you:

https://forums.jetphotos.com/forum/a...ning-from-crew

In this case #6. Please attach the EXACT image you had rejected or planned to upload....

[dlowwa]

Quality looks ok, but they both seem a bit overprocessed (contrast/shadows on aircraft look a bit unnatural) to me. Not nearly enough for a rejection from me, but can't speak for others....

[dlowwa]

Very likely a contrast rejection....

[dlowwa]

Can't judge quality on images you haven't re-edited yet....

[dlowwa]

I accepted your appeal, but in the future please come up with your own reasons for appealing rather than "screener in the forum told me to.." Someone else might handle your appeal and their opinion may differ from mine, so any future appeals from you with such comments I will simply skip.

[dlowwa]

Centering is fine now, but I don't think the quality is there for 1920pix. You'd be much better trying again at 1280....