Kyle McKinlay - Editing Advice

[KyleMcKinlay]

Do these show any improvement? Thank you!

[dlowwa]

Do these show any improvement? Thank you!

[ATTACH=CONFIG]17425[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]17426[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]17427[/ATTACH]

1. same
2. ok for me now
3. same

[KyleMcKinlay]

Thanks Dana. Do you think the wingshot will be 'fixable'? Thank you

[dlowwa]

Thanks Dana. Do you think the wingshot will be 'fixable'? Thank you

Don't think you will ever be able to get it better than borderline. Doesn't mean it's a guaranteed rejection, but unlikely to ever be sure of acceptance.

[KyleMcKinlay]

Okay, thank you for the advice. I'll upload and just wait and see Could you also kindly pre-screen the images attached below please? Thanks!

[dlowwa]

Thanks Dana. Do you think the wingshot will be 'fixable'? Thank you

[ATTACH=CONFIG]17446[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]17447[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]17448[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]17449[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]17450[/ATTACH]

2-3 ok
4. borderline contrast
5. soft

[KyleMcKinlay]

Thank you Dana. Is this better for no.5? Thank you for your time!

[dlowwa]

Thank you Dana. Is this better for no.5? Thank you for your time!

[ATTACH=CONFIG]17508[/ATTACH]

No, oversharpened now.

[KyleMcKinlay]

Okay. In any particular area? The windows/titles and green circles? Thanks for the feedback, I appreciate it!

[PrestonFiedler]

Looks to me like titles, nose gear, reg, green circles. Is it blurry? Parts of this make me think there's some blur, and the second edit also has some noise, not sure if it exceeds an acceptable amount or not.

[dlowwa]

Okay. In any particular area? The windows/titles and green circles? Thanks for the feedback, I appreciate it!

Whole aircraft. Not sure the quality is there on this one.

[KyleMcKinlay]

Hmm, if it was a regular 777 then I wouldn't be quite as fussed, but I thought the dark sky worked well with the green stickers. *Hopefully*, this is better? Tried to reduce overall sharpness, then blurred out jagged edges - mainly the titles and the tail. Thanks for your time on this one!

[dlowwa]

Hmm, if it was a regular 777 then I wouldn't be quite as fussed, but I thought the dark sky worked well with the green stickers. *Hopefully*, this is better? Tried to reduce overall sharpness, then blurred out jagged edges - mainly the titles and the tail. Thanks for your time on this one!

[ATTACH=CONFIG]17542[/ATTACH]

If I screened it I would reject for noise/compression, oversharpened, and possibly blurry.

[KyleMcKinlay]

Ah...thanks for your quick reply. Initially noise/compression wasn't an issue, would that have been a result of sharpening/blurring? Thank you.

[dlowwa]

Ah...thanks for your quick reply. Initially noise/compression wasn't an issue, would that have been a result of sharpening/blurring? Thank you.

Adding sharpening certainly will add more noise.