Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
wkd001- Editing advice
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by dlowwa View Post1. ok
2. oversharpened
3. heat haze, horizon
4. ok
I'll only try 1 and 4.
I got this one rejected for underexposed. https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7291600
I don't really agree with this one.
Despite the histogram showing a small gap on the right side on my reject page/ not in my Lightroom. I think personally the aircraft is well lit.
Adding more exposure/white to this one would result in an overexposed or even too harsh contrast (I suffered a couple of rejects for that the last time)
Also the sun on the nose is tricky for me and I don't want to touch the highlights.
Any guidance on this would be appreciated.
Also pre-screening/advice on these two would be appreciated.
Thanks in advance.
Comment
-
Originally posted by wkd001 View PostThanks Dana.
I'll only try 1 and 4.
I got this one rejected for underexposed. https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7291600
I don't really agree with this one.
Despite the histogram showing a small gap on the right side on my reject page/ not in my Lightroom. I think personally the aircraft is well lit.
Adding more exposure/white to this one would result in an overexposed or even too harsh contrast (I suffered a couple of rejects for that the last time)
Also the sun on the nose is tricky for me and I don't want to touch the highlights.
Any guidance on this would be appreciated.
Also pre-screening/advice on these two would be appreciated.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]24573[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]24574[/ATTACH]
Thanks in advance.
Comment
-
Originally posted by dlowwa View PostRejected image is a bit dark, but would have been ok for me. I'd give it 50/50 chance on appeal. The other two also look ok for me.
I would like advice/prescreen on these four images,
re-edit of this reject. https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7284569. Horizon should be good but I'm not sure about sharpness.
Especially contrast (harsh?) and sharpness.
Especially exposure.
sharpness especially and maybe contrast.
Thanks in Advance.
Comment
-
Originally posted by wkd001 View PostThanks a lot for the feedback Dana. I decided to appeal the 747 and it got accepted. Thanks for that.
I would like advice/prescreen on these four images,
[ATTACH=CONFIG]24663[/ATTACH] re-edit of this reject. https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7284569. Horizon should be good but I'm not sure about sharpness.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]24664[/ATTACH] Especially contrast (harsh?) and sharpness.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]24665[/ATTACH] Especially exposure.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]24666[/ATTACH] sharpness especially and maybe contrast.
Thanks in Advance.
2. soft towards tail
3. dark/contrast
4. borderline soft
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by wkd001 View PostOK, Thanks a lot Dana.
I would like advice/prescreen on these four images.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]24862[/ATTACH] Re-edit of #3 from the previous post
[ATTACH=CONFIG]24863[/ATTACH] Especially sharpness
[ATTACH=CONFIG]24864[/ATTACH] exposure/sharpness/contrats/glare
[ATTACH=CONFIG]24865[/ATTACH] Contrast /exposure
2: a touch soft and overexposed, mainly towards the tail
3: OK
4: contrast (tail blends into the background)
Comment
-
Originally posted by LX-A343 View Post1: contrast
2: a touch soft and overexposed, mainly towards the tail
3: OK
4: contrast (tail blends into the background)
I've only tried the third....
I got this one rejected yesterday for underexposed. https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7317094
I don't agree with this as I think that maybe the shadows are a little dark, but adding more exposure would blow the white areas really out in my opinion
Also heading to too harsh contrast with that.
I'm considering an appeal but as I'm not sure with the shadows I would like advice what to do.
I also would like advice on these two.
think it's not passable for various reason, but I want to know for sure.
Thanks in advance.
Best Regards.
Comment
-
Originally posted by wkd001 View PostThanks Geri.
I've only tried the third....
I got this one rejected yesterday for underexposed. https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7317094
I don't agree with this as I think that maybe the shadows are a little dark, but adding more exposure would blow the white areas really out in my opinion
Also heading to too harsh contrast with that.
I'm considering an appeal but as I'm not sure with the shadows I would like advice what to do.
I also would like advice on these two.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]24999[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25000[/ATTACH] think it's not passable for various reason, but I want to know for sure.
Thanks in advance.
Best Regards.
Comment
-
Originally posted by dlowwa View PostRejected image borderline, but would have been acceptable for me. Other two both borderline contrast, but would also be acceptable for me.
However, the appeal on the reject https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7317094 fell down the wrong way so I had to go back to the drawing board for it
I tried to follow the advice given in the appeal verdict and I want to know if it's better know. However, in my opinion it's pointing too a too harsh contrast
Here it is.
Also I would like prescreen/advice on these images
Centering, contrast and sharpness
Crop, centering, sharpness
crop, centering
contrast
Thanks In Advance!
Best Regards
Comment
-
Originally posted by wkd001 View PostThanks a lot Dana,
However, the appeal on the reject https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7317094 fell down the wrong way so I had to go back to the drawing board for it
I tried to follow the advice given in the appeal verdict and I want to know if it's better know. However, in my opinion it's pointing too a too harsh contrast
Here it is.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25149[/ATTACH]
Also I would like prescreen/advice on these images
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25150[/ATTACH] Centering, contrast and sharpness
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25151[/ATTACH] Crop, centering, sharpness
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25152[/ATTACH] crop, centering
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25153[/ATTACH] contrast
Thanks In Advance!
Best Regards
2. dark/contrast
3. soft
4. soft, contrast
5. soft
Comment
-
Originally posted by dlowwa View PostFirst one needs the shadows lifted a bit. This will both make the contrast less harsh, and the image appear brighter overall.
2. dark/contrast
3. soft
4. soft, contrast
5. soft
I went back to the drawing board and would like advice/pre-screen on these images.
Reworked version of #1
other snap as previous #2
very afraid on especially sharpness and contrast
Biggest issue shall be contrast.
Thanks in Advance.
Comment
-
Originally posted by wkd001 View PostOK Dana,
I went back to the drawing board and would like advice/pre-screen on these images.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25247[/ATTACH] Reworked version of #1
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25249[/ATTACH] other snap as previous #2
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25250[/ATTACH] very afraid on especially sharpness and contrast
[ATTACH=CONFIG]25251[/ATTACH] Biggest issue shall be contrast.
Thanks in Advance.
Comment
-
Originally posted by dlowwa View PostAll would be acceptable for me, though I do see 2 & 4 being borderline for color/noise and contrast, respectively.
I would like advice/prescreen on these four images.
It's another snap as this rejected image https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7344798.
Sharpness should be better on this one, but I do have a lot of concern about the contrast. if this one fails, I'll try to rework the rejected version.
Very afraid of contrast on this one.
Not sure on sharpness on this one.
Not sure on sharpness/exposure and contrast on this one.
Thanks in Advance.
Best Regards.
Comment
Comment