Makases - Editing Advice

[Makases]

Hello

I need some feedback on these two photos.

Thank you in advance.

Makases

[dlowwa]

Hello

I need some feedback on these two photos.

Thank you in advance.

1. contrast, soft
2. vignetting, borderline contrast/noisy

[Makases]

Thank you. Do you think If any of these two pics are salvageable ?

[dlowwa]

Thank you. Do you think If any of these two pics are salvageable ?

Second one might be with a better edit.

[Makases]

Can I get these photos prescreened ?

[dlowwa]

Can I get these photos prescreened ?

[ATTACH=CONFIG]21757[/ATTACH] [ATTACH=CONFIG]21758[/ATTACH] [ATTACH=CONFIG]21759[/ATTACH]

Borderline vignetting on the first two, and maybe some light dust spots/removal attempts, but they might not be noticeable enough to be an issue.

[Makases]

Another two photos for prescreening and corrected vignette on previous two photos, I dont know if the corners are too much white now.

[dlowwa]

Another two photos for prescreening and corrected vignette on previous two photos, I dont know if the corners are too much white now.

[ATTACH=CONFIG]21780[/ATTACH] [ATTACH=CONFIG]21781[/ATTACH] [ATTACH=CONFIG]21782[/ATTACH] [ATTACH=CONFIG]21783[/ATTACH]

1-2 borderline contrast
3-4 vignetting shouldn't an issue

[Makases]

What do you mean by saying "borderline contrast" ? Is it too low or too high ? Sorry, but I dont fully understand that.

[dlowwa]

What do you mean by saying "borderline contrast" ? Is it too low or too high ? Sorry, but I dont fully understand that.

Borderline = may or may not be rejected. In this case due to a lack of contrast.

[Makases]

Thank you for explaining it. Three more photos for prescreen and two with increased contrast. Maybe they look better now.

[dlowwa]

Thank you for explaining it. Three more photos for prescreen and two with increased contrast. Maybe they look better now.

[ATTACH=CONFIG]21818[/ATTACH] [ATTACH=CONFIG]21819[/ATTACH] [ATTACH=CONFIG]21820[/ATTACH] [ATTACH=CONFIG]21821[/ATTACH] [ATTACH=CONFIG]21822[/ATTACH]

Would be ok for me.

[Makases]

Nice to hear that. One more photo for prescreen :

[dlowwa]

Nice to hear that. One more photo for prescreen :

[ATTACH=CONFIG]21838[/ATTACH]

Borderline vignetting and dust spots.

[Makases]

Corrected prievious photo plus 3 more for prescreen.