new member prescreening

[bwn]

Here's the picture without the ramp worker, if that would be rejected for motive

[bwn]

I know that this is backlit, but would it make an acceptable night shot?

[dlowwa]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]23476[/ATTACH]

Is this acceptable?

No, aircraft is soft, obstructed, and even the ramper is cut off.

[ATTACH=CONFIG]23477[/ATTACH]

Here's the picture without the ramp worker, if that would be rejected for motive

Dark and dust spot.

[ATTACH=CONFIG]23478[/ATTACH]

I know that this is backlit, but would it make an acceptable night shot?

Not actually backlit, but horizon is off, and shadows a bit too strong.

[bwn]

No, aircraft is soft, obstructed, and even the ramper is cut off.



Dark and dust spot.



Not actually backlit, but horizon is off, and shadows a bit too strong.

How's this?

[dlowwa]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]23479[/ATTACH]

How's this?

Soft and compressed.

[bwn]

I removed the dust spot and brightened

[dlowwa]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]23480[/ATTACH]

I removed the dust spot and brightened

You didn't do a good job with the removal. An overprocessed/manipulation rejection would result.

[ATTACH=CONFIG]23481[/ATTACH]

I also sharpened and removed the artifacts

Horizon off again.

[bwn]

Did I fix the horizon?

[dlowwa]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]23482[/ATTACH]

Did I fix the horizon?

Yes, should be acceptable.

[bwn]

How's this now?

[dlowwa]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]23483[/ATTACH]

How's this now?

This is a different image. It is soft and the horizon is off.

[bwn]

Now?

[bwn]

Without the artifact

[dlowwa]

See here:

So...which one? Why don't you take your time and consider which images you would like looked at before you start posting them en masse.

[bwn]

See here:

The last one please