Editing Advice - Arnold Aaron

[ajaaron]

Under which category should this pic be uploaded? - Airport overview? Thanks.

[dlowwa]

Is the crop ok on this one? - I wanted to include the radar tower...

[ATTACH=CONFIG]28768[/ATTACH]

I personally don't think the tower adds much to the image, but another screener may disagree.

[ajaaron]

Is the crop ok on this one? - I wanted to include the radar tower...

[dlowwa]

Ok - just trying to understand when/how a picture would be rejected for clutter - it seems this picture below was acceptable, but you don't think my pic above would make it?

https://www.jetphotos.com/

Because that image (the link to which I have removed) should have been rejected, but was accepted by mistake.

[ajaaron]

Ok - just trying to understand when/how a picture would be rejected for clutter - it seems this picture below was acceptable, but you don't think my pic above would make it?

https://www.jetphotos.com/

[dlowwa]

Would this be rejected for obstruction/clutter?

[ATTACH=CONFIG]28642[/ATTACH]

Yes.

[ajaaron]

Would this be rejected for obstruction/clutter?

[dlowwa]

Would 1. below be classed as cutoff or would it make it?

and 2 and 3, would they be a heat haze rejection? - haze is only on ground, all of aircraft I believe unaffected by it - please confirm. Thank you.

1.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]28574[/ATTACH]

2.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]28575[/ATTACH]

3.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]28576[/ATTACH]

1. cut off
2. soft/heat haze
3. borderline soft/heat haze

[ajaaron]

Would 1. below be classed as cutoff or would it make it?

and 2 and 3, would they be a heat haze rejection? - haze is only on ground, all of aircraft I believe unaffected by it - please confirm. Thank you.

1.


2.


3.

[dlowwa]

Is the crop in this photo acceptable, or would it be a rejection for cut-off?

[ATTACH=CONFIG]28555[/ATTACH]

Subjective call. Ok for me, but might not be for others.

[ajaaron]

Is the crop in this photo acceptable, or would it be a rejection for cut-off?

[dlowwa]

Would this A380 make the grade? - Thanks.

[ATTACH=CONFIG]28467[/ATTACH]

No. Soft/blurry/heat hazed. Not fixable.

[ajaaron]

Would this A380 make the grade? - Thanks.

[dlowwa]

Would the stairs here cause a rejection for obstruction/clutter?

[ATTACH=CONFIG]28407[/ATTACH]

Yes.

[ajaaron]

Would the stairs here cause a rejection for obstruction/clutter?