User Profile

[dlowwa]

No....

[dlowwa]

This would be fixed by waiting for the clouds to pass, or coming back when there is better light....

[dlowwa]

1-2. bit soft/noisy, but would be ok for me.
3. soft, overprocessed...

[dlowwa]

1. soft, borderline color
2-3. borderline soft/contrast



Not really artistic, just regular silhouette shots. Both a bit dark/harsh contrast, and first oversharpened....

[dlowwa]

Admin Comments

Background too bright, impossible to fix the contrast issue

If it makes you feel any better, the accepted version is only marginally better, and both would have been rejections for me.....

[dlowwa]

1 & 3 would be ok for me. 2 has contrast/underexposure issues. Haze barely visible on 1, but again, not an issue for me....

[dlowwa]

Leading edge of the wing is a good place to start. Should be straight. Most definitely is not straight in this image. Otherwise the livery or anywhere else there should be straight lines that are not straight but instead wavy..again as easily visible in the above image....

[dlowwa]

1. Not going to blame the first screeners for missing it because it's hard to see with it so dark, but that's a manipulation rejection. Blurring faces is not allowed.
2-3. borderline contrast/overexposed. minimal change from the rejected versions....

[dlowwa]

Would be ok for me, but as always, that's just my opinion....

[dlowwa]

They are not worth uploading....

[dlowwa]

Soft/blurry....

[dlowwa]

Yes. For the softness as well.



No. Also dirty, overprocessed, and somewhat soft/blurry....

[dlowwa]

Well, honestly the 'full quality' image is soft (and noisy) as well, so not surprising. That said, there is enough resolution in the original that with an improved edit you should be able to hide the softness better at a lower resolution like 1280pix....

[dlowwa]

I'd say the EK would probably be a rejection, but wouldn't guarantee it....

[dlowwa]

These images are heavily compressed, so much worse than before. You need to do the opposite of whatever change you just tried....

[dlowwa]

Contrast is quite poor due to the angle of the light. You can try adding more contrast, but not sure if it's really fixable....

[dlowwa]

Some softness/heat haze visible on a couple of them (2, 3 especially), but don't see any other major issues....

[dlowwa]

First is a touch dark, and bit of heat haze on second, but they would be ok for me....

[dlowwa]

A bit bright, but otherwise ok for me....

[dlowwa]

Unfortunately not....