YanS - Editing Advice

[YanS]

Hi everyone,

Today these pictures were rejected for being backlit:

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7158226

https://www.jetphotos.com/viewqueued_b.php?id=7158222

The first one is borderline for me too but as pretty much of the fuselage is lit and as it was OK in pre-screening (which is no guarantee of course) it would be discussable in my eyes.

The second one looks ok in terms of light in my opinion.

But of course these are only personal views so I ask here if one of them (or both) would be worth an appeal.

Thanks for your help,
Best regards
Yannick

[dlowwa]

Hi everyone,

A feedback on these would be great
1.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22404[/ATTACH]
2.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22405[/ATTACH]
3.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22406[/ATTACH]
4.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22407[/ATTACH]
5.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22408[/ATTACH]

I'm not totally sure about horizon on all of these.

Thanks for your answers,
best Regards,
Yannick

Last one needs tighter crop on right, otherwise can't see any major issues with the horizon or otherwise.

[YanS]

Hi everyone,

A feedback on these would be great
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

I'm not totally sure about horizon on all of these.

Thanks for your answers,
best Regards,
Yannick

[dlowwa]

Hi everyone,

A pre-screening for these would be nice.

1.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22182[/ATTACH]
2.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22183[/ATTACH]
3.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22184[/ATTACH] ( not sure about contrast here)
4.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22185[/ATTACH] ( not sure about exposure)
5.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22186[/ATTACH] ( I don't know if the composition/crop works good enough)

Thanks for your replies,
All the best,
Yannick

PS: Is it generally ok (or even good) when we add a specific aspect to the picture that we are not sure about in pre-screeing?

3 & 5 maybe a touch soft, otherwise ok. Asking about specific concerns is fine.

[YanS]

Hi everyone,

A pre-screening for these would be nice.

1.
2.
3. ( not sure about contrast here)
4. ( not sure about exposure)
5. ( I don't know if the composition/crop works good enough)

Thanks for your replies,
All the best,
Yannick

PS: Is it generally ok (or even good) when we add a specific aspect to the picture that we are not sure about in pre-screeing?

[dlowwa]

Hi everyone,

Thanks, dlowwa, sounds good. I'll give them a chance.

A feedback on these would be great aswell:
1.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22103[/ATTACH] (not sure about contrast here)
2.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22104[/ATTACH] (I had to remove some dust here, I hope, it's ok)
3.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22105[/ATTACH]
4.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22106[/ATTACH] ( not sure about horizon here)
5.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22107[/ATTACH] ( would be borderline contrast/backlit for me and I think the colour looks a bit off too...)

Thanks for your help,
Have a good day,
Yannick

1. yes, borderline contrast
2. see something below the nose, but not really that visible
3. ok
4. dark, borderline cut off for cropping tug
5. yes, backlit

[YanS]

Hi everyone,

Thanks, dlowwa, sounds good. I'll give them a chance.

A feedback on these would be great aswell:
1. (not sure about contrast here)
2. (I had to remove some dust here, I hope, it's ok)
3.
4. ( not sure about horizon here)
5. ( would be borderline contrast/backlit for me and I think the colour looks a bit off too...)

Thanks for your help,
Have a good day,
Yannick

[dlowwa]

Hi everyone,

A pre-screening for these five would be nice:

1.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22071[/ATTACH] ( not sure about centering and horizon here)
2.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22072[/ATTACH] ( I had to remove some dust, hope it's ok)
3.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22073[/ATTACH] ( borderline contrast for me)
4.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22074[/ATTACH] ( very borderline backlit I think but on the other hand pretty much of the fuselage is lit... not sure )
5.[ATTACH=CONFIG]22075[/ATTACH] ( not sure about horizon)

Thanks for your help,
Best regards,
Yannick

Would be ok for me.

[YanS]

Hi everyone,

A pre-screening for these five would be nice:

1. ( not sure about centering and horizon here)
2. ( I had to remove some dust, hope it's ok)
3. ( borderline contrast for me)
4. ( very borderline backlit I think but on the other hand pretty much of the fuselage is lit... not sure )
5. ( not sure about horizon)

Thanks for your help,
Best regards,
Yannick

[dlowwa]

Hi everyone,

would the control-tower-picture need 'Airport-overview'-category?

Thanks for your help,
best regards,
Yannick

Yes.

[YanS]

Hi everyone,

would the control-tower-picture need 'Airport-overview'-category?

Thanks for your help,
best regards,
Yannick

[dlowwa]

Hi everyone,

Thanks dolowwa for your answer. I'll give them a chance.

A feedback on these would be nice:
1.[ATTACH=CONFIG]21905[/ATTACH] (I had to remove some dust right over the visible contrail but I didn' want to damage the contrail. I hope it's ok this way.)
2.[ATTACH=CONFIG]21906[/ATTACH]

Thanks for your replies,
Best regards,
Yannick

Second one might need a touch of CCW, but quality looks ok for both.

[YanS]

Hi everyone,

Thanks dolowwa for your answer. I'll give them a chance.

A feedback on these would be nice:
1. (I had to remove some dust right over the visible contrail but I didn' want to damage the contrail. I hope it's ok this way.)
2.

Thanks for your replies,
Best regards,
Yannick

[dlowwa]

Hi everyone,

I tried to improve no. 3 now:
1. [ATTACH=CONFIG]21833[/ATTACH] ( I think it's now bright enough but I'm afraid it's too soft now )

...And a new one for pre-screening:
2.[ATTACH=CONFIG]21834[/ATTACH]


Thanks for your answers,
All the best,
Yannick

PS: feel free to ignore the Piper for now, I attached it accidently and a 6th image would be out of the 24h limit

Both look acceptable to me.

[YanS]

Hi everyone,

I tried to improve no. 3 now:
1. ( I think it's now bright enough but I'm afraid it's too soft now )

...And a new one for pre-screening:
2.


Thanks for your answers,
All the best,
Yannick

PS: feel free to ignore the Piper for now, I attached it accidently and a 6th image would be out of the 24h limit