AaroS - prescreening request / editing advice

[Cameron Roberts]

I am unsure about the centering on this one. Is it too low in the frame?
And what about the contrast on this one?
Are the obstructions and people problematic on this one?

I could use a way higher resolution on the F-35 but I am not sure when the people in the background become a recognizable and a problem. Any advice?

Is there enough direct light and is the contrast okay? If not, do you think it can be saved in Lightroom?

Huge thanks for the help!

Hi

1. A bit low in frame
2. Harsh contrast, compression
3. No faces visible, but gate Is obstructing the front wheel, but in my opinion it is unavoidable.
4. Narrow crop (unacceptable aspect ratio)
   “Aspect ratio between 4:3 and 3:2, or at 16:9.”
5. Contrast (not fixable)

[AaroS]

Hi

1. A bit low in frame
2. Harsh contrast, compression
3. No faces visible, but gate Is obstructing the front wheel, but in my opinion it is unavoidable.
4. Narrow crop (unacceptable aspect ratio)
   “Aspect ratio between 4:3 and 3:2, or at 16:9.”
5. Contrast (not fixable)

You made me realize that I had mistyped the resolution for 4. The aspect ratio is exactly 16:9 but the resolution was too small to be uploaded.

[Cameron Roberts]

You made me realize that I had mistyped the resolution for 4. The aspect ratio is exactly 16:9 but the resolution was too small to be uploaded.

Hi, photo looks fine for me now. Might need to wait for a screeners opinion.

[dlowwa]

You made me realize that I had mistyped the resolution for 4. The aspect ratio is exactly 16:9 but the resolution was too small to be uploaded.

Oversharpened, motive.

[AaroS]

Oversharpened, motive.

Do you agree with Cameron Roberts on the other photos?

[AaroS]

Oversharpened, motive.

I assume the motive rejection is due to people being too recognizable. Are they way too easily recognized in this picture or is it borderline?

[dlowwa]

Do you agree with Cameron Roberts on the other photos?

Didn't bother to read the other comments.

1. dark
2. dark/harsh contrast
3. dark/contrast, obstruction
5. horizon, borderline dark/contrast

I assume the motive rejection is due to people being too recognizable. Are they way too easily recognized in this picture or is it borderline?

If it were borderline, I would say so.

[AaroS]

Thank you Dlowwa!

I tried to fix 1, 2 and 5:




Does this one have the motive issue too due to people?


Is the guy sitting in the shadow a problem?

[dlowwa]

Thank you Dlowwa!

1-3. borderline dark/contrast
4-5. ok for me

[AaroS]

Thanks again! I tried to fix 1-3 for the last time.



I am also unsure of the light and centering on this C-17

[dlowwa]

Thanks again! I tried to fix 1-3 for the last time.
I am also unsure of the light and centering on this C-17

1. dark
2. dark, contrast
2. borderline contrast
4. dark/contrast, horizon

[AaroS]

The wings on this one are quite bright but should the nose be a bit brighter? Is the light good?


I assume both of these are considered night shots. Any other issues?



Thanks!

[dlowwa]

The wings on this one are quite bright but should the nose be a bit brighter? Is the light good?

I assume both of these are considered night shots. Any other issues?

Images are soft/blurry, and noisy. Yes night shots.

[AaroS]

Images are soft/blurry, and noisy. Yes night shots.

Is the sharpness better on these?


Is the bright reflection of the horizon that is under the window line of this C-32 a problem?

[dlowwa]

Is the sharpness better on these?

No, now overshapened/blurry. Are you sure the quality is there on the original(s)? If so, maybe a better edit can resolve the issues, but if not they might not be fixable.