screening help for ronen_fefer

[dlowwa]

Question: is the contrast in this photo still low?
And is the photo acceptable?

Yes, still a bit low. Also borderline soft.

[ronen_fefer]

Question: is the contrast in this photo still low?
And is the photo acceptable?



Thanks in advance.

[dlowwa]

Hi Could someone prescreen this photo?

Would be rejected for too far, vignetting, dust spots, and possibly contrast.

I am not a screener. As far as i know, the sun is higher than the aircraft. From this angle, there's no sunlight ON the aircraft.

That is incorrect. The sun is on this side of the aircraft, so it is not backlit.

[LuftSpotter]

Hi Could someone prescreen this photo?

thanks in advance!

I am not a screener. As far as i know, the sun is higher than the aircraft. From this angle, there's no sunlight ON the aircraft. This photo's chance doesn't look good.

[ronen_fefer]

Hi Could someone prescreen this photo?

thanks in advance!

[dlowwa]

Will this work?
I think its quite high right here to be honest.

Still well below the centerline, but your call. I won't comment on this any more.

[ronen_fefer]

Still too low. Crop a bit tighter and put it higher:

Will this work?
I think its quite high right here to be honest.

[dlowwa]

Ok so I tried to fix the issues that you have brought up, and these are the results:

Still too low. Crop a bit tighter and put it higher:

Now I'm not sure which one is more acceptable in terms of compression the first one (quality=100) or the second one (quality = 60)?

First, not even close. Never use anything less than 100 quality.

[ronen_fefer]

Crop is ok, but too low in the frame, and borderline quality (softness, contrast, compression) for 1920pix.

Ok so I tried to fix the issues that you have brought up, and these are the results:

Now I'm not sure which one is more acceptable in terms of compression the first one (quality=100) or the second one (quality = 60)?

[dlowwa]

Will this work?

Crop is ok, but too low in the frame, and borderline quality (softness, contrast, compression) for 1920pix.

[ronen_fefer]

Will this work?

thanks in advance.

[dlowwa]

you mean its uncentered basically?

And needs a tighter crop, yes.

[ronen_fefer]

This would be rejected for too far/centering. Processing is not an issue.

you mean its uncentered basically?

[dlowwa]

fixed, though the only problem I could find is HALOS around the wing but I'm not sure if they are enough to reject my photo, could someone help me here?
i have added the equalized version for reference.

This would be rejected for too far/centering. Processing is not an issue.

[ronen_fefer]

Images larger than 1920pix cannot be submitted to the queue.

fixed, though the only problem I could find is HALOS around the wing but I'm not sure if they are enough to reject my photo, could someone help me here?
i have added the equalized version for reference.

Thanks in advance Ronen.