Semjons Fiskiss - prescreening request / editing advice

[SemjonsF]

Sorry, you didn't understand me.

Borderline = 50% yes, 50% no
Probably ok = 75% yes, 25% no
Probably not ok = 25% yes, 75% no
Ok = 100% yes (for me)
Not ok = 0% yes

Ok, now I got it, got it.
Will this one be better?

[dlowwa]

Ok, now I got it, got it.
Will this one be better?

Ok for me.

[SemjonsF]

Ok for me.

Great.

How about these two?
That crop like that is fine?
Is there not too much pink tint in Qatar?

[dlowwa]

Great.

How about these two?
That crop like that is fine?
Is there not too much pink tint in Qatar?

Both heat hazed, especially the first. Yes, slight pink/magenta tint on the second.

[SemjonsF]

Both heat hazed, especially the first. Yes, slight pink/magenta tint on the second.

Ookaaaay. But would that amount of pink tint be fine or would it be considered overediting?

[dlowwa]

Ookaaaay. But would that amount of pink tint be fine or would it be considered overediting?

It would be considered bad colour.

[SemjonsF]

It would be considered bad colour.

Alright, thanks

[SemjonsF]

Prescreening, please

[dlowwa]

Prescreening, please

No need for 4:3, but otherwise ok for me.

[SemjonsF]

No need for 4:3, but otherwise ok for me.

I am sorry, I didn't quite understand. Would this get a rejection because there is too much space due to aspect ratio being 4:3, which is what I always try to use?

[dlowwa]

I am sorry, I didn't quite understand. Would this get a rejection because there is too much space due to aspect ratio being 4:3, which is what I always try to use?

Not a rejection reason, just aesthetically unappealing imho.

[SemjonsF]

Hi! Prescreening, please.

[dlowwa]

Hi! Prescreening, please.

Dirty, overprocessed, and no real need for 4:3.

[SemjonsF]

Hello. Prescreening, please.

[flyetty]

Hello. Prescreening, please.

For me,
1. Too far
2. Maybe contrast/dark
3. Maybe too far or more space on one side
4. Dark/contrast/Heat hazed