Tom Smart - prescreening request / editing advice

[Alex - Spot-This !]

I would say it's fine. Nice photos as well

cheers
Alex

[[email protected]]

Alex - Spot-This ! Thanks a lot!

[[email protected]]

Hi there. A few questions on some potential uploads:
1. Heat haze?
2. Noise? Contrast? (last light of the day)
3. Similar? (https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/10764216) This image seems better than my last one.
4. Would the mismatched parts qualify this as "hot?"
5. Vignette? This one was rejected for that reason - have I sufficiently controlled that now?

Thanks.

[dlowwa]

Hi there. A few questions on some potential uploads:
1. Heat haze?
2. Noise? Contrast? (last light of the day)
3. Similar? (https://www.jetphotos.com/photo/10764216) This image seems better than my last one.
4. Would the mismatched parts qualify this as "hot?"
5. Vignette? This one was rejected for that reason - have I sufficiently controlled that now?

Thanks.

1. dirty, contrast, color
2. color, compression, vignetting
3. centering, dirty. yes similar
4. ok for me. not hot.
5. ok for me

[[email protected]]

dlowwa Great. Thanks for the feedback

[[email protected]]

Trying to sort out the "foreground clutter" criterium. Also "motivation" and "cropping." Thanks for your help.

[dlowwa]

Trying to sort out the "foreground clutter" criterium. Also "motivation" and "cropping." Thanks for your help.

Minor bit of haze so sharpening might be an issue on some. Otherwise mostly ok for me.

[[email protected]]

These are images that I've sat on for a while.. Could you offer your opinion about the strength of these images? Thanks a lot.

[dlowwa]

These are images that I've sat on for a while.. Could you offer your opinion about the strength of these images? Thanks a lot.

1. contrast
2. color, soft/blurry
3-4. dark/contrast, color
5. backlit

[[email protected]]

Great thanks. I needed help exploring those boundaries.

[[email protected]]

Questions when you get a chance:
1-2 I dragged the shutter on these to blur the background; is the subject too blurry?
3 Contrast?
4 Does this work as a spotting location photograph?

[dlowwa]

Questions when you get a chance:
1-2 I dragged the shutter on these to blur the background; is the subject too blurry?
3 Contrast?
4 Does this work as a spotting location photograph?

1-2. not bad, but indeed too soft
3. contrast borderline at best
4. generally fits what we're seeking for this kind of image

[[email protected]]

1-3 Obstruction? Blurry?
4 Horizon?

[dlowwa]

1-3 Obstruction? Blurry?
4 Horizon?

1-3. if not obstruction, then contrast/motive.
4. horizon looks ok to me