michaelsb - prescreening request / editing advice

[dlowwa]

Thanks for the feedback on that. Does this look any better or should I save it for keepers?

That would be an overprocessed rejection.

[michaelsb]

That would be an overprocessed rejection.

Thanks for the feedback. I went with another frame in the burst. Let me know your opinion. This will be my last attempt and I won't bother with it any longer if it's not worth posting and I'll save it for the collection. Cheers!

Michael

[dlowwa]

Thanks for the feedback. I went with another frame in the burst. Let me know your opinion. This will be my last attempt and I won't bother with it any longer if it's not worth posting and I'll save it for the collection.

Very soft/nearly blurry.

[michaelsb]

Opinion on these? Thanks!

Michael

[dlowwa]

Opinion on these? Thanks!

Light is a bit harsh, but they would be ok for me.

[michaelsb]

Opinion on this one? Thanks! Also thanks for the upsize limit to 1920 pixels. Going to try this one at 1600.

Cheers!

Michael

[dlowwa]

Opinion on this one? Thanks! Also thanks for the upsize limit to 1920 pixels. Going to try this one at 1600.

Soft/noisy/harsh contrast.

[michaelsb]

Thanks. This one is a bit tricky with the contrast. I re-edited, noise reduction etc. Is this an improvement?

Michael

[dlowwa]

Thanks. This one is a bit tricky with the contrast. I re-edited, noise reduction etc. Is this an improvement?

Still dark/contrasty, and not sure the quality is there for 1600pix.

[michaelsb]

Thanks. Alright, I resized it to 1280pix and reworked it . Would this be alright now?

[dlowwa]

Thanks. Alright, I resized it to 1280pix and reworked it . Would this be alright now?

Still borderline soft/dark.

[michaelsb]

Thanks. Any improvement? Not sure if I sharpened it too much. Cheers!

Michael

[dlowwa]

Thanks. Any improvement? Not sure if I sharpened it too much. Cheers!

Still borderline. Not going to comment on this one again.

[michaelsb]

Still borderline. Not going to comment on this one again.

ok